Immigration

My Name is Prerna and I am Undocumented

Published December 20, 2008 @ 11:25AM PT

Cross-posted at Desicritics.org.

You Passed the US Citizenship Test

Congratulations - you got 10 out of 10 correct!

“You can no longer claim legal residency under the petition filed by your grandmother. You are over 21 now and aged-out under the I-130,” said my latest attorney. I didn’t quite understand what he meant, the fear and confusion hidden in my nervous laughter.

“You are joking, right? They didn’t give me an F-1 visa to study here because my parents had filed for permanent residency and now you are telling me that I can’t get the permanent residency for which my visa was initially rejected?” I tried to grapple with the logic of the law.

He shrugged, like it was no big deal. “You luckily have a 245-I and can get a Green Card in several years once your parents file for you again. Or you can just get married to a U.S. citizen,” he offered.

“What? I have already waited a decade and marriage doesn’t help me—I am gay,” I answered, gyrating at the reminder of how another set of discriminatory laws worked against me.

“You can always get a marriage of convenience?” he shrugged.

I am writing this on International Migrants Day – In all seriousness, every day should be a day to celebrate migration but there is a story to the migration of my people that I have not blogged about.

http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/1351/img00403655920xm0.jpg

My sister (29) and I (24) have both been here for a decade. We have grown up American, we are both hard-working, hold advanced degrees, possess great English skills, and even look alike but there is a fundamental way in which we are different: she is a US citizen while I am undocumented; she has grown up legally in America, while I am an ‘illegal alien.’

The ‘attrition through enforcement’ advocates often tell DREAM Act beneficiaries to go home to our countries. I want to know what that means:

Fiji: The country where I was born tells me that I am a colonizer, that I don’t belong there.

India, Pakistan and Bangladesh: The countries of my ancestry predetermine me as a criminal even though I have never stepped foot anywhere in the Indian subcontinent.

The United States of America: The country where I have spent close to a decade, continues to demand a Green Card and a nine-digit number in order to accept me, regardless of the fact that the rest of my family comprises tax-paying citizens and legal permanent residents.

As a Pacific Islander of undocumented status, I am consistently relegated to a parenthetical and non-existent status in the legal-illegal immigration binary. While illegal presence is not a crime, since the tag of “illegal alien” comes with an assumption of criminality, I am wrongfully deemed a criminal. At the same time, I have had to challenge the additional presumption of foreignness based on language, the stigma of both gay and ‘illegal’ in the Indo-Fijian community, and stemming from that, cultural, economic and structural limits to inclusion in my home.

What is American? Who is an American? I hail from the Fiji Islands; My favorite food is Chinese; I root for Italy and Juventus when it comes to soccer; I am disappointed when India loses a major cricket tournament; I love Pakistani music with Jal as my most favorite band; I speak several dialects of Hindi, English, understand Urdu and am finally grappling with Spanish and French; the L-word is my favorite television show with Jennifer Beals as my biggest idol; I think Indian actress Anita Hassanandani is the most beautiful woman in the world; I love Maroon 5, Simple Plan, U2 and Kasabian; my best friends live in various parts of the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom; the San Francisco Bay Area is my home and Chicago is my favorite city. My likes and dislikes know neither borders nor boundaries. And if my diversity of taste and pleasure-seeking avenues is not American, than I don’t know what is.

With multitudes of identities in this world of constructed binaries and boundaries, I have multitudes of questions. What precisely is my home country? Where do I belong? Why am I being punished for something that was out of my control? Why does this country not consider me equal to the rest of my family? Why can’t I use my postgraduate education to help my family, community and country in these tough economic times? Why can’t I get married to adjust my status? How does deporting me help legal residents and U.S. citizens whom I help every single day?

I work 15-20 hours a day for pro-migrant, pro-LGBT civil rights reforms. This is not merely a job or a cause; it is about our lives. And I plan to stay here, attend law school, become a public interest lawyer, and serve my community. The DREAM Act can help make this a reality for me and countless other students who are rendered stateless in the only country they know as home.

For weeks, I had been nicknamed the V for Vendetta for the DREAM Act movement. That phase is over - DreamActivist, the blog handle for Brave New Films, has now transformed into a rallying point for the United We DREAM coalition. I have lost an identity for myself, but we have gained momentum for the DREAM Act in 2009. Goodbye DreamActivist. Welcome DreamACTivist - United We DREAM.

So in the Harvey Milk fashion, I would like to begin by saying that my name is Prerna (meaning ‘inspiration’ in Hindi), and I want to recruit you in the fight for our limpid dreams.

Please support higher education for all children and help us make the DREAM Act a Top 10 Idea.

Visit and even register at DreamActivist.org for more information and to receive updates on how you can help us in this struggle to achieve our DREAMs.

http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/4148/50p6579ia4.jpg

Share this Post

Related Posts

Comments (36)

  1. Prerna Lal

    Thanks Dave.
    http://desicritics.org/2008/12/20/083524.php
    Crossposted at Desicritics that is also 'honoring' me for the 'coming out.'

    By the way, I have done some interviews with Dreamies -- this was a good one, maybe we can borrow questions -->
    http://adreamdeferred.org/blog/36997-meet-a-dreamer-i-fear-i-ll-be-another-lost-statistic

    Posted by Prerna Lal on 12/20/2008 @ 12:57PM PT

  2. Brian Mason

    When will we all realize that we are all immigrants or decendant from immigrants in this country, except for the few thousand "native Americans" who probabloy immigrated just several thousand years before the rest of us?

    Those of us who got here first, have always had a problem with those coming after us, who only want the same thing we or our ancestors wanted.  We need to abandon this narrow-mindedness and embrace all who want to follow their dreams.

    Can we just throw out the current immigration laws and start over with a new paradigm?  I wish.

    Posted by Brian Mason on 12/20/2008 @ 01:09PM PT

  3. Maria M.

    Prerna, thanks for sharing your amazing story and fighting so hard for the passage of the DREAM Act. We'll definitely fight along with you to make our dreams a reality once and for all. DREAM Act in 2009 for sure!

    Posted by Maria M. on 12/20/2008 @ 02:21PM PT

  4. Frank Franca

     I am deeply offended by the choice of Rick Warren for the inauguration invocation. I was planning on going to DC to join in the celebrations but have now canceled my trip. How could I be present at an event partly presided by someone so divisive and dimissive of me as a human being.  I worked so hard to get Mr. Obama elected, and now I feel like he has taken my support for granted. If he wanted to be inclusive, he should have chosen to include those of us who have been excluded for the past 8 years, not someone who represents religious thinking under the Bush Administration. This type of political pandering, and politics as usual "payback" is not what I imagined I would be facing before Mr Obama even takes office. It also makes me reevaluate Mr Obama's sincerity about all of the other issues on which he campaigned. I imagined Mr Obama ro be someone I could be friends with, who probably had friends like my friends. With the choice of Rev. Warren he has demonstrated to me that the characterization of "the other" used to smear him by his political enemies during the campaign might actually be accurate. He certainly does not feel like "one=2 0of us" to me any longer... I can't imagine that now that Mr Obama has been elected my sincere comment here will make any difference to him or to those working with him, but on the off chance that anyone even bothers to read these things anynore, I want to convey in the strongets way the tremendous feeling of being used, and deceived that I and my friends and family are feeling by this act of betrayal to his core base, in an effort to pander politically to group of people who did not supprt him, and did not vote for him. I would like to recieve a personal response to this note...
    Regretfully
    Frank Franca

    Posted by Frank Franca on 12/20/2008 @ 07:34PM PT

  5. Isabel Reyes

    prerna, you are so amazing. you're truly the embodiment of all the good things the DREAM Act stands for. =]

    Posted by Isabel Reyes on 12/21/2008 @ 01:40PM PT

  6. Prerna, your story lingered with me all weekend after I read it on Desicritics.org. It will remain close to me much longer than that.

    While many of us are aware of the historical injustices in our immigration policy based on race and ethnicities, many are unaware of equal injustices based upon sexual orientations. Again, it is a biased policy reflecting the cultural "norms" of those with the power to make the policy.

    My thoughts, my heart, my spirit are with you in your courageous journey. Together, united with the knowledge that our fight is a fight for justice for all, we shall overcome.

    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/22/2008 @ 06:26AM PT

  7. Luis  Ramos

    my name is prerna and I am illegal

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 12/24/2008 @ 04:05PM PT

  8. My name is Luis and I cannot tell the difference between a noun and an adjective.

    No human is illegal. But some sure are dumber than others and they like to show it off.

    Is FAIR missing its village idiot?

    I dont care if I get banned for this...

    Merry Christmas.

    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/24/2008 @ 10:53PM PT

  9. Prerna Lal

    Illegal? Lol.
    HIM? Lmao.

    Do you have any actual claims + warrants to make besides adjective/noun and gender confusion?

    Thanks, made my X-mas quite merry :)

    Posted by Prerna Lal on 12/26/2008 @ 02:10PM PT

  10. Mayday Martin

    No human being is illegal but human beings do illegal things.

    Posted by Mayday Martin on 12/26/2008 @ 05:18PM PT

  11. Dreamer X

    Yes, mayday but not all illegal things are done in purpose, just like the Deserving outstanding individuals the DREAM ACT will support.

    Posted by Dreamer X on 12/27/2008 @ 09:39AM PT

  12. Children do not determine where their parents will move to-whether it is to the suburbs or another country in search for work.

    The Dream Act protects children who should not have to suffer for the acts of their parents. What and why their parents immigrated here is another issue. The Dream Act is about the children.

    The Dream Act allows all of us to benefit from the talents that these children have. They should not have to live in silent desperation with a status that limits their opportunities.

    People who would intentionally hurt children because they cannot get over their hate are mean spirited.

    A mean spirit is an illness. It is also legal.

    There are some here who gladly brag about being ill-legal.

    Pete


    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/28/2008 @ 07:42PM PT

  13. Dreamer X

    Luis,

    US citizens and Legal immigrants already has the DREAM ACT and not all actually earned or deserve it.

    DREAM ACT is for victims that don't deserve to be victimized. It's for young people who deserve better.

    Posted by Dreamer X on 12/28/2008 @ 08:45PM PT

  14. Luis  Ramos

    There are many U.S citizens and legal immigrants who do not deserve what they hav or will get. But there isn't an illegal immigrant who deserves the priveliges or rights of a U.S citizen.

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 12/29/2008 @ 12:42PM PT

  15. Dreamer X

    You tell that to the illegal immigrant who were among the first casualties of the Iraq War, Luis. They were granted automatic citizenship after they're dead. What's the use of it wheen theyre dead?

    Posted by Dreamer X on 12/29/2008 @ 01:08PM PT

  16. Mr. Ramos,

    That is only your opinion. Sadly, your argument is based on opinion.

    There are many documented cases of children of undocumented immigrants who have attended college, worked hard, and displayed exemplary behavior. I would argue that these facts would make one deserving of the privilege of a pathway towards a legal status in our nation. This will not be determined on opinion. it will be determined by fact.

    The facts are that children should not have to be penalized for the behaviors of their parents. The facts are many of these children have gone on to become college students, hard workers, and exemplary neighbors. We all benefit from having their contributions in our communities as educated, high earning tax payers.

    They were raised here without a say where they could move and live.

    I was just a lucky stiff who was born here.

    My grandparents came here during the Mexican Revolution.

    They were the latest immigrants of my ancestors to come to this area. I can say with certainty that many of my ancestors have traveled the corridors of this land long before the Romans built roads to connect their empire.

    I wonder how your ancestors came to America?

    Don't tell me they were Cherokee royalty?

    Or better yet from the Iroquois Nation.

    Todos somos inmigrantes.

    Some are just luckier than others.







    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/29/2008 @ 01:13PM PT

  17. Nilav Bhadra

    Wow Prerna.I cant imagine the pain You have gone through.I am for the same country of origin you are from, India and i study here as an international student.I see so many students every day in college who has fantastic grades but an uncertain future.I cant even imagine the strength they have for doing so good in their studies although they know they will not get hired in positions that they trully deserve.A lot of people who takes USA for granted would have given up.I am sure of that.I salute to these undocumented student's courage.I trully feel bad that some americans do not recognise this tremendous waste of talents.Education is the birth right for everyone regardless of nationality.Its more shameful when it comes to denying young students who wants and can change the face of USA for good.But i trully believe Dream Act shall pass in 2009 and bring relief to thousands of my undocumented friends all over USA.Dont loose hope Prerna.I am sure things will change for the better and all you heroes will triumph in 2009.You guys are nothing short of heroes in my views.God bless.

    Posted by Nilav Bhadra on 12/29/2008 @ 03:11PM PT

  18. Ronnie

    You are jumping all over the place in your effort to develop a rational argument. Your argument is made of opinion and old regurgitations that you think will come true if you just throw out there up enough times.

    First, if Prerna is now 24 and lived here for 10 years I would say she grew up here. That is over 40% of her life Ronnie.

    Who are you to tell her what the "right thing" for her to do?

    Prerna is not a ping pong ball. As a child she had no power
    to dictate to her where she was going to live. She had to follow her parents. Now you want to compound the injustice by telling her she still has no power to dictate where she wants to live?

    What part of "She grew up here" do you have a problem understanding?

    By Prerna wanting to remain here you try to associate her with hundreds of billions because of "crime associated with illegal immigration."

    What? Do you make this stuff up on the fly? Can you not do better than this? Is this your "A" game?

    Again, you cannot make something true just by throwing it out there multiple times in multiple on-line sites.

    She is not a criminal.

    So the people who support the Dream Act are "lazy."

    I work, raise a family, I have volunteered with the homeless and elderly, I facilitated a substance abuse group throughout the past summer,and I just graduated in August with a Masters. I do not know one lazy person who supports the Dream Act.

    Again, just because you huff and puff and blow some lies out does not make it true.

    Too bad you ran out of steam at the end and digressed into a senseless rant.

    You are the best hope for the passage of the Dream Act. There is no way that the mainstream America will listen to the mean spirit and confusing accusations that drive your "debate" when they balance it out with what the Dream Act is really about.

    It is about justice for children. The Dream Act will pass.

    Also,"No Human is Illegal."

    Although some are sure mean spirited.






    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/29/2008 @ 06:44PM PT

  19. Luis  Ramos

    Children who was brought here illegally with their parents are in a sense being punished for the actions of their parents. The ones punishing them ARE THEIR PARENTS. Because they either didn't want to appy for a citizenship or just didn't want to find a legal way to get a better life for them, they think by sneaking into the country their problems would just go away. But since it has not, They decided to "teach" their kids on "racist" this country is against immigrants, when in reality, we are only angry at illegal immigrants.

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 12/30/2008 @ 06:04AM PT

  20. Luis Ramos offered:

    "Children who was brought here illegally with their parents are in a sense being punished for the actions of their parents."

    In a sense? Minimizing reality?

    Not many things in life are black and white but the fact is that the children did not determine where they were moving to. Decent people understand that fact. You understand that sir. Most of us have some decency inside us. Even you cannot argue that point with any truth, conviction, or believable passion. Thus, you grasp at twigs to formulate an argument.

    "they either didn't want to appy for a citizenship or just didn't want to find a legal way to get a better life for them,..."

    If it was that easy to find an easy legal way to get here and stay here do you not think that every person who crossed the harsh, unforgiving Sonora Desert would have gone that route instead?

    Ever been to Southern Arizona in the summer?

    But back to your latest offering."... in reality, we are only angry at illegal immigrants." Really? Minimizing again? Why hurt the kids then? They were brought here without choice.

    I would suggest that this needs to be resolved with level heads on all sides. Anger has no place in the equation.

    A level head tells me that the Dream Act is not about illegal immigration. It is not amnesty. It is about children and providing opportunities for them to openly share their skills and talents with the America they grew up in.


    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/30/2008 @ 06:45AM PT

  21. Luis  Ramos

    Minimizing reality?
    Why hurt the kids?///

    Their parents chose to come illegally
    Their parents chose to stay illegally
    Their parents chose not to do anything to fix their citizenship status

    Yet you want to blame the U.S government for not wanting grant them amnesty and give them everything that U.S citizens have to sacrifice for and/or denied on a silver platter. In case you don't know what I am saying, THE PARENTS ARE THE ONES THAT HURT THE KIDS.

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 12/30/2008 @ 07:12AM PT

  22. Luis Ramos,

    Posting in caps does not make your weak argument any stronger.

    But please keep posting in angry tones. Your mean-spirited anger against children will be the deciding factor in the inevitable implementation of the Dream Act.

    You are barking at the moonless sky when the real issue is about the children. You cannot make this into an illegal immigration issue when it is about the children. Keep howling and drag yourself down your exclusive streets at dawn looking for your angry fix to beat on the illegal immigrant. (apologies to Mr. Ginsberg)

    It is all about the kids. But back to your post.

    So, Looie, who is blaming the government for anything? Supporters of the Dream Act are not into distributing blame, instead they are into finding a real solution.

    Again, the Dream Act is not amnesty.

    It is an act that would give children the opportunity to come out of the shadows and share their considerable skills and talents with the rest of the nation.

    Skills and talents that are exhibited in Prerna and thousands others who study, work hard, and produce. By the way she scored a 163 on her LSAT.

    In my work I always need to find the underlying currents of the "why."

    Why would you punish these kids simply because, of your own admission, their parents hurt them? What is your true motivation
    Mr. Ramos.

    Your responses are beginning to sound more and more like a form letter from FAIR.


    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/30/2008 @ 09:43AM PT

  23. yawn


    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 12/30/2008 @ 09:19PM PT

  24. Prerna Lal

    Michael, LR and Ronald:

    I am neither asking for assistance nor handouts. I am completely capable of making it on my own without any help. I received my MA when I was only 22 despite dozens of obstacles. Legalization would remove a crucial barrier I face towards becoming a public interest pro-bono lawyer and serving my community.

    Do you seriously advocate that America should not legalize me and get me to pay taxes to this country for the amount spent on my secondary school education? So I should take the education I have gotten here, take my professional degree somewhere else (Canada, Australia, UK), and never contribute back to the United States? I am completely gung-ho about that option, ready to self-deport myself back to Fiji for 3 months and spend another 3 months on a world tour, except for one fact -- my family is in this country, they are legal residents, and if I dare step out I get slapped with a 10 year ban.

    The DREAM Act would allow me and so many other students in my situation to give back to the only country they call home - the United States of America. Not tapping into this vital resource is bad public policy, forget about the inhumanity behind punishing youth for crimes they never committed.

    Posted by Prerna Lal on 12/31/2008 @ 12:44PM PT

  25. Mo A

    "They came here legally, went through all the necessary steps, expect to speak English and pledge to the American flag every day."

    =========================================

    You must not have met many Dreamies, we can speak english just fine. . . in fact many of us without any accent!

    How can you blame someone for not going through the "neccesary steps" when they have never been given the option to do so?

    The DREAM Act does exactly what you want, it provides a line to children who have no line to get into.

    You do not understand the subject you are speaking of, you said some nice patriotic sounding things but I have to wonder when being ignorant became the "American" thing to do?

    Posted by Mo A on 12/31/2008 @ 03:50PM PT

  26. mikey, you sound like a broken record from FAIR. Got anything original. The oldies are a little moldy by now.

    ronnie hollowell, deport all illegals? Illegal what? Are you using the word as a noun? Listen to your comrade Mikey and speak English.

    Still I bet you were proud of your post. I cant wait for the next brilliant offering.

    Does Roy Beck dictate every post? They all sound the same whether it is Luis, Ronnie S., mikey and Ronnie H.


    Shrill baby shrill.

    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 01/01/2009 @ 01:17AM PT

  27. Luis  Ramos

    Pete, is that how you end debates? By acting like a three year telling people the same thing over and over again, saying we just repeating the same argument when you don't like it when we are not sympathetic of illegals?

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 01/01/2009 @ 05:02PM PT

  28. Prerna Lal

    "They came here legally, went through all the necessary steps, expect to speak English and pledge to the American flag every day."
    ________________________________________

    -My family communicates mostly in English. I speak English better than my own language(s). In fact, I scored a 5.5/6 on the GRE English writing, above 90% of all students who sat the test that day.

    -We have an American flag planted firmly in front of our house.

    Posted by Prerna Lal on 01/01/2009 @ 07:20PM PT

  29. looie,

    We were in a debate? Is that what you actually thought? 

    let us review your debating skills.

    Looie: my name is prerna and I am illegal

    Looie: There are many U.S citizens and legal immigrants who do not deserve what they hav or will get. But there isn't an illegal immigrant who deserves the priveliges or rights of a U.S citizen

    Looie:

     

    Three year old? So you calling me a name makes me a three year old. About that ability to think critically...

    Sir, you are the best argument for the Dream Act. Mainstream America, filled with decent people, will easily see your inability to even develop the simplest argument without the aid of Roy Beck.

    I could not care less if you had sympathy for anyone. You have chosen your side. Your attempts to win anyone else towards your side needs to be stronger than calling people illegals.

    I do have empathy, passion, and compassion for the young people who will be freed from the shadows to openly share their considerable skills and talents with all of us.

    I strongly believe that the decency of the American public will ignore your redundant shrills and support an act that is about the children. If you do not like me repeating it then I suggest that you go running back to the comfort of the FAIR folks.

    Oh, by the way Mr. Ramos, if that is even your real name since you sound like just another over-matched FAIR plant,

    No Human is illegal.

    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 01/01/2009 @ 08:09PM PT

  30. illegal teens

    Terrorists and Criminals

    Illegal Aliens Who Lack Good Moral Character

    The tone of your post says it all. Decent people will see through this mean spirited attempt to attached these negative and untrue lables to children.

    No teen is illegal.

    No human is illegal.

    Posted by Pete Coyotl on 01/04/2009 @ 04:22PM PT

  31. William C

    If you're the pretty one, I'll marry you :) Just kidding, already married.

    Posted by William C on 01/08/2009 @ 09:14PM PT

  32. Prerna Lal

    Dave -- There is NO chain migration with DREAM. If the parents are here illegally, they get no repreive. To be sponsored by their over 21 children, they would need to go back home for 10 years and come back. THAT is the law of the land. You may want to check into it. Besides, I don't need to sponsor my parents; they would need to sponsor me, and of course there are backlogs for that as well.

    Once someone reaches over 21, they are no longer covered under their aunt's or grandma's petition, which is precisely what happened to me. Again, you may want to check into U.S. immigration law and the complicated numerical calculations of CSPA.

    You may want to read the story of Chip Gilea as well
    www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlyZf-ojRfI

    Son of U.S. citizens who was facing deportation ... Yeah, the 'law of the land' works really well at tearing U.S. citizens and permanent residents from their children.

    Lol, sorry William, both of us are unavailable ;)

    Posted by Prerna Lal on 01/10/2009 @ 09:32PM PT

  33. Dave Avery

    "In June, 2007 a solid eighty percent of the American people let Congress know
    they wanted the government to put the brakes on illegal immigration; they
    turned thumbs down on the President's guest worker amnesty plan; and they
    wanted tax-paid services to illegals stopped.

    Most Americans understand that new laws are not needed to stop illegal
    immigration. What is necessary is repeal of some laws granting
    taxpayer-financed services to illegals along with enforcement of existing
    laws. These two acts would be enough to stop the migration. In simple fact,
    they are called "illegal" because they are breaking the law.

    In truth, the battle over the Senate's guest worker-amnesty plan is really a
    battle over attempts to open the border as called for in programs such as
    North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and the Security and Prosperity
    Partnership (SPP). Both plans call for open borders and economic integration
    of North America. Open borders are required to fully implement the plans.

    The Bush Administration and those promoting illegal immigration were frankly
    stunned at the force and determination of U.S. citizens to reject the
    Senates immigration plan. Proponents played a very heavy hand in attempting
    to force the scheme on a resisting citizenry. Such powerful forces are not
    used to losing. Today they continue to seek new ways to work around the
    opposition and pass the legislation, as a whole or incrementally.

    However, the anti-illegal fervor refuses to abate and in fact, dramatic new
    developments are taking place in local communities across the nation that
    may well stop the unpopular Federal schemes.

    Meanwhile, in an attempt to weaken the resolve of opponents, they are called
    fringe fanatics. A common tactic employed by immigration proponents is to
    accuse opponents of racism. They charge that opponents want to deny a new
    breed of immigrant the chance to become Americans as many of our immigrant
    forefathers did. They paint a Norman Rockwell-type picture of honest, hard
    working immigrants, planting gardens, working in fields, doing the work "no
    Americans want to do."

    So, in town after town across the nation the battle rages. And that is
    really the point. Illegal immigration is not just a border issue. It is a
    national issue affecting every large city and almost every small town. It
    must be understood that illegal immigration is not just a matter of some
    unhappy peasants hoping to seek a better life. It is a $300 billion a year
    industry, combining the interests of multinational corporations with those
    of drug cartels and Latino street gangs. Caught in between are American
    communities and the American way of life. Some cities, especially those
    along the points of entry at the border have become dangerous no-mans lands,
    where no property is safe, no American citizen is able to leave their home
    unarmed and some politicians turn a blind eye as they profit under the
    table. As a result American civilization is beginning to break down. That is
    why so many Americans refuse to back down on the issue, continuing to demand
    a crack down, no matter what name calling they must endure.

    THE ECONOMIC COST OF ILLEGALS

    Federal law (the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act) mandates
    that all hospitals with emergency-room services must treat anyone who shows
    up - including illegal aliens. In most cities across the nation, illegals
    now use the emergency rooms as free primary care. And the hospitals have to
    keep taking them.

    Health Care

    The annual cost for uncompensated emergency care to Mexican Border States
    (California, New Mexico, Arizona and Texas) is $200 million. California
    taxpayers paid $79 million for illegal alien health care. Four major Los
    Angeles hospitals were bankrupted and shut down in 2004. Texas paid $74
    million. Georgia ran a $63 million deficit for 64,000 unpaid doctor visits
    in 2002. Cochise County, Arizona spent 30% of its annual budget on
    uncompensated care to illegal aliens. University Medical Care in Tucson,
    Arizona spent $10 million on uncompensated care to illegal aliens. 77
    hospitals in the four Border States now face financial emergencies. Legal
    citizens are forced to fly emergency patients to other cities for treatment.
    Taxes are going up to compensate.
    Meanwhile, as a result of the Federal Emergency Medical Act, Mexican
    ambulance drivers are transporting hospital patients unable to pay for
    medical care in Mexico to facilities in the United States. The ambulances
    are driving through unguarded potions of the border with "little resistance"
    at the instruction of Mexican officials.

    Education

    Federal laws and a Supreme Court decision mandate that schools cannot deny
    free education to illegal aliens. Over 300,000 pregnant women enter the
    nation illegally every year. Taxpayers pay for food, housing medical care
    and school. The average annual cost per child for education is $7,161,
    totaling $109 billion to educate illegal aliens annually. The average cost
    of bilingual education is $1,200 per illegal student. U.S. schools annually
    educate 1.1 million illegal children. Schools have become over crowded and
    unruly. Teacher shortages (especially those who speak Spanish) are a growing
    problem for local school districts.

    One teacher has reported what it is like in the classrooms in schools where
    federal tax dollars pay for free medical, free baby sitters for student
    mothers as young as thirteen, and free breakfasts (where "the waste of food
    is monumental, with trays and trays of being dumped in the trash uneaten"),
    new computers are "carved with graffiti by students." "I have had to
    intervene several times for young and substitute teachers whose classes
    consist of many illegal immigrant students here in the country less than
    three months who raise so much hell with the female teachers, calling them
    "Putas" (whores) and throwing things that the teachers were in tears" she
    reports. Such is the atmosphere in today's schools which are overrun by
    illegal aliens who speak no English and there is no ability to control or
    discipline.

    Moreover, state run colleges and universities are being forced to allow
    illegal aliens to receive in-state tuition discounts that are supposed to be
    reserved for residents of that state. In California, a law, (Assembly Bill
    540) allows undocumented high school graduates who have been in residence
    for three years to enroll in community colleges and the California State
    University and University of California systems without paying nonresident
    tuition. The same is true in many other states across the country.

    The Jobs Americans Don't Want

    In 2003, illegal aliens displaced American workers at a cost in excess of
    $133 billion, while American college and high school students can't find
    summer jobs in yard care, landscape, fast food or service jobs - because
    illegal aliens work those jobs at a third of the wage - often under the
    table.

    Crime

    Crimes committed by alien criminals, such as rape, murder or drug
    distribution costs U.S. taxpayers $1.6 billion in prison costs alone. The
    figure doesn't include the cost of lost property, medical bills of the
    victims, time lost from work to recover, higher insurance costs, etc. Today,
    illegal aliens make up twenty nine percent of the U.S. prison population -
    or 500,000 illegals.

    Latino gangs like Mara Salvatrucha 13 (MS13) constitute most of the crime
    from the ranks of the illegals. They originated in El Salvador and today
    their U.S. leadership still comes from there. They steal cars and use them
    to run drugs over the border. They terrorize local citizens with violence.
    They are the chief source of drug sales for the cartels. And they are
    racists.

    MS13 is the largest and most violent of all gangs in the US today. They have
    overtaken the Crips and the Bloods both in size and violence. MS13, which
    began its operations in Los Angeles has now moved east and is prominent on
    the East Coast.

    In Los Angeles, Mexican gangs declared "ethnic cleansing zones" in specific
    parts of the city. They kill whites and blacks. In New Jersey, recently,
    MS13 gang members killed three college students in execution style.

    NO MANS LAND AT THE BORDER

    No legal citizen of the United States of America, living under the
    Constitution and the Bill of Rights should have to live as those who reside
    near the U.S. / Mexican border. Here there are no property rights, no
    ability to be safe in their homes, and no peace. One dare not go to the
    movies, the grocery or visit a relative without carrying a weapon for
    protection. Through out the community the streets are teaming with drug
    dealers, loiterers and gangs bent on violence.

    The illegals flood across their property having just crossed the border. As
    they pass over the ranches and private property they leave a trail of trash,
    human waste and dead farm animals and pets. Found in the trash that is
    dropped all along the trail are pieces of paper containing contact phone
    numbers. Also found are Korans dropped by obvious Muslims who have made
    their way across the border.

    Sometimes the illegals walk right in to the living rooms and steal what they
    want. Many homes on the border are now little more than prisons for the
    residents, surrounded by barbed wire, searchlights, with loaded guns at the
    ready.

    The Tucson, Arizona area is one of the prime crossing points for illegals.
    The organization for transporting illegals is almost a precision military
    operation. On the Mexican side of the border is a landing strip where planes
    fly in on a regular basis with their cargo. Some of it human; some drugs. It's
    all the same to those providing the transportation.

    The planes land and the cargo is loaded onto busses with the windows whited
    out. Young girls prepare for the trip by taking birth control, for they know
    what awaits them on the trip across the border from their "travel
     assistants" - rape. It's just part of the price for crossing the border
    into the promised land of America.

    The busses drive to a specific location on the border. Here the cargo is
    unloaded and the process of walking across the border begins. Each of the
    human cargo is given information on what to do once they reach the other
    side, including a phone number of someone to call. The number is not
    necessarily a local number. It may be a location in Virginia, or Maine or
    Utah. Anywhere in the U.S. The person on the other end gives instructions on
    how to gain transportation to their location where they will be brought into
    the illegal community in that city.

    And so the journey across the border begins. Somewhere in the middle,
    between Mexico and the U.S. is a tree. From the branches of that tree hang
    women's panties. It's called the panty tree. Why? Trophies from the raped
    women of previous journeys. It's just the cost of doing business with the
    "Coyotes," the murderous thugs who run the illegal immigrant trade. They don't
    care who lives or dies. These are the ones who will leave illegals locked in
    trucks without food or water or ventilation. They charge enormous fees - up
    front. To them the cargo is all the same. They carry the drugs with the
    humans. They make deals with terrorists for the same trip. They rape, maim
    and kill. And go back for another load. Business is booming.

    Once the cargo is inside the U.S., more buses are there to pick them up and
    transport them to drop off points. Here the phone calls are made for
    arrangements of more transportation across the nation. And in that highly
    organized manner, illegal aliens make their way into American cities.

    Some are "Sanctuary Cities" where politicians have decided it's good for the
    community to encourage illegals to live. In such communities no one can ask
    for the country of origin, even if a crime as horrible as murder is
    committed. The sanctuaries permit 20 million illegals, drug smugglers, child
    sex rings, ID forgery networks, and an assortment of run of the mill
    criminals to live lawlessly inside the United States. They are provided with
    income, identification, driver's licenses, credit, housing, education, and
    medical care at taxpayer expense.

    As stated, it's a $300 billion a year industry. That buys a lot of
    politicians. Along the Border States no one talks about it. And, no
    surprise, a lot of politicians do nothing to stop it. Our fear and their
    greed are destroying the American dream.

    MEANWHILE IN YOUR LOCAL COMMUNITY.

    How a community treats the illegals is key as to how many come there. The
    main magnet is the establishment of a day labor center. The nation-wide
    illegal network knows where to send them. If a community opens its arms, of
    course they flock there. If a community stands up to them, they leave.

    But that is easier said than done. First, federal laws or lack of
    enforcement hampers efforts against the illegals, no matter the sentiment of
    the community. Federal courts strike down local laws, such as just happened
    in Hazleton, Pennsylvania when a federal judge degreed that laws the
    community had passed to crack down on illegals were unconstitutional.
    Federal agencies say it is illegal for local police to ask if anyone is an
    illegal. The federal government argues that immigration is a federal issue
    and for local communities to take action interferes with U.S. foreign
    policy.

    On the local level too, there is great pressure on elected officials to do
    nothing. Strong lobbying arms protect the illegals. The ACLU, of course,
    threatens lawsuits. But many Americans would be surprised to learn of the
    Hispanic forces behind much of the pressure applied to their local
    officials.

    Many immigrant groups are joined together through the La Raza movement.
    These are the groups which organized the massive demonstrations in cities
    across the nation last year. It is past time for all Americans to know what
    is at the root of those demonstrations and the extent to which our nation is
    at risk to the La Raza movement.

    One of the most prominent Hispanic organizations pushing for "immigrant
    rights" is the National Council of La Raza - the Council of "the Race." The
    mainstream media and most members of Congress depict La Raza as little more
    than a Hispanic Rotary Club. In 2005, La Raza received $15.2 million in
    federal grants, of which $7.9 million was in U.S. Department of Education
    grants for Charter Schools, and undisclosed amounts to get-out-the-vote
    efforts supporting La Raza political positions including lobbying for open
    borders and amnesty for illegals. Had the Senate's immigration bill passed,
    several million more dollars were budgeted for La Raza.

    Behind the respectable front of the National Council of La Raza lies the
    real agenda of the La Raza movement. This radical agenda, pushed by
    secondary groups contains the reasons behind the demonstrations and the
    strong lobbying efforts in our communities.

    Key among those secondary groups is the radical racist group Movimiento
    Estudiantil Chicano de Aztlan, or Chicano Student Movement of Astlan
    (MEChA). MEChA seeks to carve a racist nation out of the American West.
    MEChA opposes assimilation into American society. MEChA is a leader in the
    effort to "Reconquista" or reconquest our western states.

    MEChA's founding principles state: "In the spirit of a new people that is
    conscious not only of its proud historical heritage but also of the brutal
    gringo invasion of our territories, we, the Chicano inhabitants and
    civilizers of the northern land of Aztlan from whence came our forefathers,
    reclaiming the land of their birth and consecrating the determination of our
    people of the sun, declare that the call of our blood is our power, our
    responsibility, and our inevitable destiny.Aztlan belongs to those who plant
    the seeds, water the fields, and gather the crops and no to the foreign
    Europeans.For La Raza to do. Fuera de la Raza nada." That closing
    two-sentence motto is chilling to everyone who values equal rights for all.
    It says: "For The Race everything. Outside The Race, nothing."

    These words don't come from a fringe radical element. These come straight
    from the official MEChA sites at Georgetown University, the University of
    Texas, UCLA, University of Michigan, University of Oregon, and many other
    colleges and universities around the country.

    Another leading Hispanic group involved in community organization, promoting
    the pro illegal position is Mexicanos Sin Fronteras. The translation of the
    name means "Mexicans Without Borders." This group is active throughout the
    country and many times works with the "Zapatista Army of National
    Liberation." These groups seek to radicalize the Latino community. The
    official website of the Mexicanos Sin Fronteras states that it is
    "anti-capitalist, anti-imperialist in the capital of the most terrorist
    country of world-wide history" (Washington, DC). It goes on to say it
    pledges its support to "other campaigns" of the radical illegal Hispanics
    with material and financial assistance.

    In Manassas, Virginia the Mexicanos Sin Fronteras and the Zapatista Army of
    National Liberation are the two most prominent "pro-Hispanic" voices. In
    fact, these two groups are spearheading the illegal alien lobby in Prince
    William County, where Manassas is located. This is the "mainstream
    opposition" to efforts to curb illegal immigration in that community.
    Together, these groups are holding rallies and calling for boycotts and even
    the violent overthrow of the United States. Again, these groups are not
    fringe radicals. They are the most prominent voices for the illegals.

    The photo on this page is of a meeting in Mexico with many of these groups.
    It is interesting to note that speaker in this picture, with his face
    covered, is Arnoldo Borjas a member of Mexicanos Sin Fronteras and a
    resident of Woodbridge, Virginia. He is one of the main leaders in that
    local movement. Further, in Prince William County, there are several
    candidates running for local office as well as the state legislature who are
    closely aligned with these two radical organizations.

    FIGHTING BACK

    While Congress fiddles and the Bush Administration issues meaningless
    pronouncements on "get tough" programs it never intends to enforce, local
    communities and state legislatures are beginning to fight back. And they are
    meeting with success.

    State Legislatures, forced to deal with the failure of the federal
    government to fix the immigration laws, have considered 1,404 immigration
    bills this year and enacted 170 of them. These laws are aimed at curbing
    employment of illegals and making it more difficult to obtain state
    identification documents like driver's licenses.

    In May, Oklahoma passed the "Taxpayer and Citizen protection Act" which
    denies illegals state identification, and requires all state and local
    agencies to verify citizenship status of all applicants before authorizing
    benefits.

    On the local level incredible success is being achieved in Northern
    Virginia. Last year two residents of Herndon, Virginia, with no prior
    political experience, began an effort called Save Herndon. The issue was the
    establishment of a day labor center in the community. The center would give
    illegals a gathering place in the community to help them get jobs,
    identification and benefits from the community.

    The two began a campaign that at once made a major issue out of the
    establishment of the center. When the mayor and the city council moved
    forward and voted to establish the center over the objections of a majority
    of the citizens, Save Herndon began a campaign to assure these
    representatives were not re-elected. They succeeded beyond their wildest
    expectations, helping to out the mayor and everyone on the city council who
    voted for the center.

    Now the movement is growing across the Northern Virginia area. There is now
    Help Save Manassas, Help Save Loudoun (County), Help Save Fairfax, Help Save
    Virginia and Help Save Maryland. Together these purely grassroots movements
    have succeeded in enacting legislation in Loudoun County (the nation's
    fastest growing county) and in its neighbor, Prince William County which
    stops county tax-payer services to illegals. Incredibly, under challenge
    from federal and state officials, the members of county commissioners are
    holding tough behind the laws.

    The key, as stated earlier, is the day labor centers. If your city has one,
    then the message has gone out to the illegal infrastructure that your
    community welcomes them. Get rid of it and send the message that they are no
    longer welcome. If faced with lawsuits from the ACLU and La Raze, welcome
    them. Tell them you will gladly have a news conference to discuss their suit
    in front of the cameras. Do not be afraid.

    Here are a few guidelines to help organize locally and face the coming
    onslaught of charges of racism.

    DON'T express anger at what is happening to your community. DON'T express
    annoyance because illegals refuse to assimilate into your community or abide
    by your customs. DON'T make the issue economic and safety issues.
    Overcrowded housing and commercial vehicle zoning violations or that
    specific individuals are illegal aliens.

    The pro-illegals will try to tell the public that there is uncertainty as to
    who is illegal, creating doubt. They will talk about how impossible it is to
    check everyone's legal status. It will be easy to charge racism.

    Instead, make the issues about the abrogation of law. Focus your efforts
    against the individuals, businesses and politicians who create this problem
    and cheat honest business owners and workers by allowing illegal hiring
    practices under the table. In short, make the issue about enforcement of the
    law, cost and corruption. It's working in Virginia."

    Posted by Dave Avery on 02/04/2009 @ 07:49AM PT

  34. MInute Man Pete

    That is sum mighty fine cuttin' and pastin', can you teach me how to do that?

    "In June, 2007 a solid eighty percent of the American people let Congress know
    they wanted the government to put the brakes on illegal immigration; they
    turned thumbs down on the President's guest worker amnesty plan; and they
    wanted tax-paid services to illegals stopped.

    I think it was sumthing more like in 2007 a few hundred nativitists sent thousands of e-mails and fax (USANumbers and FAIR were helping send the faxes out) to the congress and senators.

    But in November of 2008 when everyone had only ONE vote it was a different story. In the 60 most contested congressional contests where there was a considerable difference in the candidate's stance on immigration, 39 were won by the pro-immigration reform candidate. In 21 districts the seat changed party hands with pro-immigration democrats winning 19 0f those 21 seats. Imagine that?

    In November of 2008, 24 members of the anti-immigration reform group "The House Immigration Reform Caucus" were up for reelection. Only 14 won their races. Other incumbents won at a 75% rate.

    So I guess when the nativists have only one vote and cannot rant over and over thousands of times in e-mails and faxes then their numbers are not so impressive.

    But I am sure you can find some more myths in your nativists sites that you can cut and paste to disprove me.

    From the size of your post, I think it may be the only thing that you do all day long.





    Posted by MInute Man Pete on 02/04/2009 @ 10:06PM PT

  35. Reply to thread
  36. Dave Avery

    Pete Coyotl         MInute Man Pete

    Different name,same game!

    Posted by Dave Avery on 02/06/2009 @ 03:12AM PT

  37. Dave Avery

    You know   MInute Man Pete if you want people to "Reply" to your comments,you should allow it instead of  "Send a Compliment"

    Posted by Dave Avery on 02/06/2009 @ 03:27AM PT

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

Author

Twitter Feed

Prerna Lal

Prerna obtained her Masters degree in International Relations in 2007 and took a hiatus from academia. During this break, she co-founded DreamActivist.org and helped launch a program for immigrant youth in the Bay Area (S4FC). Currently, she is also a Managing Editor at The Sanctuary. Views expressed on this blog are her own and not that of any organization currently affiliated with her. Contact email - prerna@change.org

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.