Immigration

Include Funding for ESL in Immigration Reform

Published August 17, 2009 @ 05:42AM PT

[Ed.: This guest post comes from Sara Sadhwani, Immigrant Rights Project Director at Asian Pacific American Legal Center & Will Coley, Aquifer Media]

The Asian Pacific American Legal Center of Southern California has released four video shorts calling on Congress to enact a fair and humane immigration reform that includes measures to support the successful integration of immigrants. Through the video project, APALC set out to raise the voices and perspectives of adult English language learners within the larger national discussion surrounding immigration .

Learning English is a cornerstone of integration for immigrant communities, but the road to fluency is long and challenging. Our research and outreach to Asian American and Pacific Islander communities as well as broader immigrant communities has shown that immigrants want to participate in building a bright future for the United States.

Unfortunately, timing played a critical role in this project. We quickly found that, due to budget negotiations in the State Assembly, the ground was shifting beneath us as well as for the adult school and community college administrators we contacted. California has the largest adult education system in the country that is supported in large part by state funding. While the current fiscal crisis in the state has forced these schools to trim their class offerings, these programs are pressing forward to meet the demand from their communities.

Over the past few months, we visited a dozen adult education schools in Los Angeles and Orange counties and met determined administrators, passionate teachers and lots of eager students. These videos capture the energy of the adult schools and document the need for increased support. “Finding Their Way in English” is the one closest to our ideal of community participation. Will Coley filmed the footage but the students came up with the idea and volunteered for the acting. Like so much social media, these videos were built on real world relationships. It took several weeks of visiting the class and getting to know them gradually. We talked a lot about how much they appreciated the English classes and wanted to see them continue. The final “script” was how the students thought they could portray the importance of English to them: finding their way in a new country.

There is no easy solution to the fiscal crisis California faces, but inclusion of immigrant integration measures such as funding for ESL programming, in a larger immigration reform package could be an important step to maintaining the adult school system.

Special thanks to Moby for donating background music.

Learn more here about how you can support adult English language learners.

---------------------

The videos in the series include:

Class Room 206: Making Time for English
In one representative class room in Evans Adult School, California's largest adult school English language program, students and teachers discuss how new immigrants make time to learn English.

Finding Their Way with English
Students in the Torrance Adult School program created this video to show what their English classes mean to them.

The Outcome is Income: Graduating in English
Through the lens of three adult school graduations in Los Angeles County, we learn what English acquisition means to the financial success of new immigrants, their communities and our nation as a whole (this video is included at the top of this post).

Why I Volunteer to Teach English
Volunteers speak about their work with L.A.M.P. (Literacy for All of Monterey Park).

Share this Post

Related Posts

Comments (66)

  1. Mark  Lindley

    The reason we have had a problem with making sure that "immigrants" learn English is because in the past couple of decades we have been overwhelmed with "immigrants" coming here in large numbers from one particular ethnic group illegally.  They have colonized rather than assimilating.

    That is one of the reasons that we have limits on legal immigration and that is to control the numbers so that assimilation does occur and that there aren't too many from one ethnic group.  It isn't rocket science.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/17/2009 @ 06:24AM PT

  2. Reply to thread
  3. Liquids Reign

    Why should the American people pay for the instruction? Why can not the "immigrant" pay for their own classes? It would be no different than attending college for anybody else.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/17/2009 @ 09:58AM PT

  4. Wire Paladin

    Or why not admit only those immigrants who pass a fluency test?  In other words, make it part of the visa application process.  Out-source the language instruction component.  Why not, we out-source other American jobs to foreign nations.

    Posted by Wire Paladin on 08/17/2009 @ 11:36AM PT

  5. Thank you, Sara and Dave, for posting this.  It's sad to see what's happening to adult ESL education in the state of California.  As to the question, Why should Americans pay for ESL instruction for immigrants?, because it's the right thing to do.  These English learners are part of our communities and they contribute to our economy through their taxes.  An immigrant who can to speak English increases his income by 15 percent, as the professor mentioned.  This helps the economy in states like California with large immigrant populations. And these are some of the hardest working people I know.  They work very long hours, yet have the discipline to attend English classes after a long, hard work day.  One woman I know has three young children, yet she works ten to twelve hour shifts cleaning office buildings (she works the night shift).  Then she makes her way to ESL classroom every day after work.  Her dream is to become a U.S. citizen. Now, if someone is willing to work that hard to realize her dreams, don't you think she deserves a shot at becoming an American? Every teacher dreams of having students like this. These students have extremely difficult lives, yet they are extremely committed and hard-working.  Aren't these the kind of folks we need in our country?  They have the same work ethic and values of every true American.  I say they deserve a shot at the American dream.

    Posted by a d on 08/17/2009 @ 04:13PM PT

  6. Liquids Reign

    Nobody is denying them the American Dream. To become a citizen, English is a requirement, it should be their responsibilty to learn it and pay for it. Anybody who works here pays taxes, your excuse is pointless. The 15% you speak of benefits them on the backs of the US Taxpayer. The little additional in taxes, again is pointless.

    because it's the right thing to do. by who's idealogy? If this is your answer than, I don't agree.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/17/2009 @ 04:50PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 2 people like this comment.   Like
  7. Arvida Brustad

    My Father born in 1916 of Swedish & Norwegian parents arrived in Portland, Oregon speaking only his native language with no formal education. He was five years old with a brother seven years old. They were enrolled in public school and they had to learn English by total immersion as did the millions of European immigrants who entered the USA.  My grandparents learned to speak English by reading the Oregonian Newspaper.  No one has ever explained why the US taxpayer has to pay for ESL in schools and for adults.  Why can't they learn English just like the millions of European immigrants?

    Posted by Arvida Brustad on 08/31/2009 @ 01:57PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  8. Reply to thread
  9. Mark  Lindley

    It all depends on whether we are referring to legal or illegal immigrants, doesn't it?  We all know how some like to blur those lines, don't we?   I would beg to differ that the illegal kind are all hard working and working numerous jobs and paying their fair share of taxes and learning English.   Most don't  work any harder than most Americans do.   That is ridiculous stereotyping.

    Many of those in our country illegally do not feel the need to learn English.  They live in their ethnic neighborhoods and do not assimilate like legal immigrants do.   See my first post in this topic for further clarification.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/17/2009 @ 05:36PM PT

  10. You couldn't be more wrong.  Most new immigrants do care to learn English and they make Herculean efforts to do so, considering the long hours they generally work.  They do some of the hardest work for the lowest pay in some of the most dangerous jobs.  Most Americans refuse to do these jobs for such meager pay, and the immigrants do pay their fair share of taxes for the most part.  As a teacher, I do not distinguish between students who are legal or undocumented.  I see human beings with potential.  These students are a cultural asset to our society in an increasingly globalized world.  We have as much to learn from them as we have to teach -- that is, if could learn to grow beyond bigotry and intolerance.

    Posted by a d on 08/17/2009 @ 06:15PM PT

  11. Liquids Reign

    They do some of the hardest work for the lowest pay in some of the most dangerous jobs.

    Why is that?

    Most Americans refuse to do these jobs for such meager pay

    Some of the most dangerous jobs? Americans refuse to do these jobs for meager pay? I suspect you are doing nothing more than spouting rhetoric here. Dangerous jobs require safety programs and safe working conditions, which in turn demands higher pay and costs. Why should a citizen risk their life for meager pay in non-safe working conditions?

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/17/2009 @ 06:37PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  12. Kurt Thialfad

    The most dangerous job in America is coal mining, almost entirely performed by Americans.  Second comes the Marine Corps., though they are not currently operating in the US.

    A  cooking job can be dangerous if you don't know how to use a stove, don't know how to use mechanical appliances and knives, can't read directions, and can't understanding warnings spoken in English 

    Posted by Kurt Thialfad on 08/17/2009 @ 09:53PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  13. Reply to thread
  14. Anthony Stephens

     

    We need to return to the fundamental understanding that immigrants have been an integral part of America's success. We realized this as a nation when the founders of our constitution intentionally steered from making English the language of the land, understanding that the original 13 colonies had their own richness in diversity amongst the other European settlers like Germany and the Netherlands. Rather than ground our country in rules that exclude, they lifted up values that include, focusing their attention on things like opportunity, mobility, and economic security. 

     

    I presently live in a neighborhood on the northern edge of Manhattan which is over 95% foreign born. It's energy is like that of Little Italy during the 1930s, or the Brooklyn Germanic neighborhood of Williamsburg during the 1870s. These neighborhoods were often urban slums, rooted in the only wealth most immigrants had, the wealth of the community that first welcomed them. It took a willingness by the greater community to help assimilate them more fully into American society. We see the benefits when looking across the Hudson River at New Jersey, a state that has long lifted up community values. Twenty percent of New Jersey residents are foreign born, and they contribute roughly 26% of the overall tax base in the state.

     

    If California wants to secure its own future, it must continue to lift up programs that include, rather than exclude. Like New Jersey, it has been a gateway for immigrants. When looking at its current broken economic system, there's great opportunity to promote real solutions like furthering English Language Learning (ELL), which clearly helps to lift us all up together. And isn't that what real change should do?

     

    Great video, and keep spreading the word for greater inclusivity in our own communities. 

     

    Posted by Anthony Stephens on 08/18/2009 @ 08:06AM PT

  15. Wire Paladin

    ... an integral part of America's failure, as well.

    Are you foreign-born?

    Posted by Wire Paladin on 08/18/2009 @ 10:39AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  16. Anthony Stephens

    Real change never comes easy, but it brings about a greater good. Not that it should matter from where I come, but I was born on the Southside of Atlanta, remembering very well from my childhood--in the years following MLK's death--the growing pains of a New South reluctant to change. some members of my own family had a hard time adjusting to desegregation. While Washington fought for real ways to fix broken laws that denied opportunity, I knew many folks personally who met change with resistance. Let's hope that with our easy access to information, change in attitudes toward inclusivity will move much faster amongst the masses.

    Posted by Anthony Stephens on 08/18/2009 @ 11:57AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 2 people like this comment.   Like
  17. Reply to thread
  18. read withcare

    Thank you for posting these great videos. They are a great reminder that there is no better school for the American Dream than in our nation's ESL classes. Supporting the integration of our newest Americans not only drives our economy, spurring entrepreneurship and innovation, but it also injects vitality into our deepest held beliefs about civic participation and political liberty. And THAT's what our great country is all about.

    Posted by read withcare on 08/18/2009 @ 10:12AM PT

  19. Cole Burns

    People fail to realize that the reason these immigrants didn't learn English before they moved here and need taxpayer help to take classes now is the same reason they came here in the first place: they're dirt poor and their own countries don't care enough about them to offer them a decent education in the first place.  Most of us at least have the opportunity to learn a second language in high school (even if we forget it later) and hardly anyone in America is desperate enough to risk their lives to sneak into another country, let alone one in which they don't speak the language.  We take these things for granted.

    Posted by Cole Burns on 08/18/2009 @ 11:52AM PT

  20. Wire Paladin

    Americans sneak into countries all the time - just watch the news: N. Korea (Current TV journalists), Iran (Cal grads), Miramar (the swimmer); etc.  These countries just don't put up with it.

    People who are dirt poor stay in their own countries because one needs to have some means to travel, unless of course, they are financed by the smuggling gangs.

    Posted by Wire Paladin on 08/18/2009 @ 01:33PM PT

  21. Cole Burns

    Interesting that you choose N. Korea as an example of how we ought to run any part of our country.

    And no, the people who are dirt poor do not stay in their own country except when they're from 1st world countries like America because nobody here can imagine traveling more than 2 miles a day without a car.  The dirt poor in other countries get here on their God given means of travel: their feet.

    Posted by Cole Burns on 08/19/2009 @ 02:55AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  22. Wire Paladin

    Well, I could have chosen Mexico, Turkey, Spain, France, England, Ireland, etc. N Korea just happened to be in the news recently in a story about Americans entering their nation illegally.  I'm not suggesting the US act like N Korea, I would recommend the US act like other modern developed nations.

    The dirt poor utilize criminal gangs to get into the US.  This is undisputable.

    Posted by Wire Paladin on 08/19/2009 @ 10:34AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  23. Reply to thread
  24. The US should follow the Canadian model - many more free services for immigrants, including English classes, English higher education testing classes, job and resume training, and job placement services.  And how is Canada's economy doing compared to the US?

    Posted by Tina Shull on 08/18/2009 @ 04:11PM PT

  25. Mark  Lindley

    If someone is coming to work here legally aren't they already required to have some sort of command of the English language?  If they are coming here as a relative of a citizen who is sponsoring them doesn't that make them  the  responsibility of that citizen as far as upkeep, etc.   They should be responsible for paying for their ESL classes then.

    As far as those in our country illegally, it matters not how hard they work, or what jobs they are doing or for what pay.   They have no right to work or to be in this country, period!   So this discussion about them learning English is a non-issue.   

    As was pointed out in here, Americans do dangerous jobs also and there are very few jobs that Americans won't do for a fair and liveable wage.   For those that cannot be filled by an American the answer isn't to hire illegal labor.    There are many jobs that can be filled by an American but in the past couple of decades many employers have decided to circumvent our immigration and labor laws to line their pockets from cheap illegal labor.   How in the world can any loyal American go along with this program?

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/19/2009 @ 06:01AM PT

  26. Alejandra Garcia

    Those who work are already paying taxes, its deducted out of their checks.  Therefore, legal or not, they are paying taxes.  They are making a great effort to learn English because they know that they should learn the language.  In high school I knew students taking ESL classes that helped them assimilate, and now they speak English well.  They work hard, and they deserve to learn English, is not asking much.  Remember this country was founded by immigrants, and this is what has made the U.S. what it is today, a melting pot....

    Posted by Alejandra Garcia on 08/19/2009 @ 11:04AM PT

  27. Mark  Lindley

    Not all are paying income taxes.   Many are being paid under the table.

    Yes, this country was founded on immigrants but they came here legally.   That is the big difference.  

    Why so little respect for our immigration laws?  You do know they are in place because it is in the best interests of this country, don't you?

    Sorry, to disagree with you but I feel that those in our country illegally deserve nothing but deportation as our laws demand.  Learning or teaching them English is irrelevant when you consider that.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/19/2009 @ 11:17AM PT

  28. Gary Stein

    I'm a jack in the box, you never know where I'll pop up Mark. 

    In a thread this morning in another story that shall remain nameless, I was talking about Beto again (Mark remembers the name) and how at the pre-cast company he worked at (where all the Mexicans paid income taxes even though most where not here legally) one or two of the Americans supervisors used to borrow money from these Mexicans and not pay the money back- although they would put a good word in with the mostly absentee owners to get these “creditors” (my word) a raise.  The Mexicans figured they’d come out ahead in the long run with the raises these rat finks got them and they considered the loans a “write off,” (my word again) or the cost of doing business and not knowing the language well.  Beto who learned to speak English pretty well used to intervene sometimes, or he would go to the bosses himself and get these guys a raise (without the red tape i.e., loaning an American money).   Dave and ana lisa, are you starting to see why I loved this guy so much?

    By the way ana lisa, I think I mentioned Beto (for anyone just joining in, Beto is back in Mexico) was asking me to call the old work place and try and get a recommendation that he could use to convince the other rats in this story, the bureaucrats in Mexico, that he was qualified to look for work in Canada in construction.  He’s half given up on that farm job he and I found together in Toronto (again, anyone just joining in- go to www.steinforgovernor.com to understand what the heck I’m talking about)   I spoke to one of the owners today, he directed me to speak with the Puerto Rican supervisor *****, he’s still there ana lisa.   Although the owner was nice, I could detect some nervousness in his voice, why, because when you’re half breaking the law you can’t trust anyone, and he wasn’t sure about me. 

    I tell people like Mark over and over that nothing is black and white.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/19/2009 @ 08:43PM PT

  29. Reply to thread
  30. Wire Paladin

    Sorry, guys but the founding fathers (with the exception of Hamilton who was born in St.Croix of an American mother) were all native-born Americans.

    This "nation of immigrants" concept is a myth and an oxymoron, much like "WoodStock Nation".

    Posted by Wire Paladin on 08/19/2009 @ 11:26AM PT

  31. Gary Stein

    Friends I just added a comment on the gay issues side of the blog again http://gayrights.change.org/blog/view/students_vs_the_defense_of_marriage_act  Ana lisa, after this weekend I swore I was going to stop writing crazy style, but why don’t Wire Paladin and all of you giddy yup over there and see what got my ire going all over again.  (and again, and again)

     

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/23/2009 @ 01:45PM PT

  32. Alex Godoy

    Number one, hopefully the article is referring to "immigrants" to those who legally came to this country. Illegal aliens don't count here, because they are not immigrants, they are criminals.

    Second, of course immigrants MUST learn English if their willing is to live here and naturalize. However, THAT IS NOT RESPONSIBILITY OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. Learning English MUST be a requirement for every immigrant, but THEY are absolutely responsible for learning the language. Proof of that, I am an immigrant. I learnt English, all by myself, because my dream was to be an American. Today, I am an American, with no affiliation to any foreign flag, country or language, other than The united States of America and its people.

    Remember: For every immigrant, it is the greatest honor and priovilege in the world, to come to the most powerful empire ever created by men. it is in their best interest, to assimilate 100%, adopt the culture, lifestyle, values, way of thinking.

    And to be honest with you, I have seen from personal experience that a great mahority of immigrants, specially hispanics, do not want to learn English. They don't like it, they don;t like this country, they don't like American people, they are here just for the opportunity; but their objective and agenda is to create here a second country where they can keep all they like and drain this system. So no, negative. I WILL NOT pay through my taxes to any kind of program that rewards people who are not 100% committed to this country.

    Posted by Alex Godoy on 08/23/2009 @ 06:28PM PT

  33. Dave Bennion

    For every immigrant, it is the greatest honor and priovilege in the world, to come to the most powerful empire ever created by men. it is in their best interest, to assimilate 100%, adopt the culture, lifestyle, values, way of thinking.

    There's a lot to unpack there, but I imagine there are many U.S. citizens who can find something to disagree with in that statement.

    But I do appreciate the power of the ideology of universalism that the U.S. represents--it often however falls short.

    i believe that many of the immigrants in those videos are doing their best to learn english and contribute to their communities and their new home in the face of difficult circumstances.  i had the privilege of being able to stay in my country of birth, so the immigrant experience is always something i only have vicariously.  i thank you for sharing your experience with the rest of us.

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/23/2009 @ 08:51PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 2 people like this comment.   Like
  34. I have seen from personal experience that a great mahority of immigrants, specially hispanics, do not want to learn English. They don't like it, they don;t like this country, they don't like American people, they are here just for the opportunity; but their objective and agenda is to create here a second country where they can keep all they like and drain this system.

    Mr. Godoy,

    As a teacher and a person of mixed-race (Latina/white), I couldn't disagree with this statement more.  You are painting all Latin@s with the same brush, which is the essence of bigotry. However, I say this respectfully. As an immigrant yourself, you surely know how painful it can be to feel like an outsider.  You, like many immigrants -- including those Latin@ Americans --have a strong desire for acceptance and inclusion.  Some immigrants make the unfortunate mistake of thinking that if they bash other immigrant groups, they will appear more acceptable to American-born citizens.  This is a grave mistake, because the folks who are engage in this "good v. bad immigrant" dichotomy generally don't distinguish between the two.  An accent marks you and so will dark skin as the perennial outsider.  People who are xenophobic and bigoted are generally fearful of all outsiders, although they are loathe to admit it.  After working with many students from many different countries, I can assure you that my Latino students are just as conscientious and hard-working as the rest.  I can appreciate that you have a unique experience and perspective as an immigrant to any country.  I think you mentioned at one point that you were from  Latin American country yourself, no? I would just ask that you show respect for everyone who may be reading this blog, because your words have the power to wound people -- including the many hard-working Latino immigrants who are my students, family and friends.  Thank you.

    Posted by a d on 08/24/2009 @ 06:48PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  35. ...can appreciate that you have a unique experience and perspective as an immigrant to **this** country (*any was an error).

     

    Posted by a d on 08/24/2009 @ 06:54PM PT

  36. Gary Stein

    small world ana, did you know I'm friends with Chris who's just below this comment?

    Chris that lady you're stringing along won't see this if I post it here. Even so I hasten to warn all that "nothing is black and white in this screwy world."  Reverend Governor in another incarnation

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgB3r53YYlk

    And  p.s. Chris glad you enjoyed Don Ameche and Francis Langford as the Bickersons

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/24/2009 @ 07:34PM PT

  37. Gary,

    Please do me this little favor. I got your email -- the one you forwarded to Dave.  Listen, please don't go and get yourself banned from this site.  Try to listen to what Dave is saying to you, and stop commenting on the gay rights blog so much...unless you have something genuine to contribute to the discussion -- that is, on topic! It begins with listening to people and understanding their concerns.  You know, it's probably the single most important thing you can do for your campaign, too (take a hint from Obama).  If you must post free-association style comments, send them to me instead, k? You've got my email. I am positively swamped with work right now, so I can't respond to all your emails.  However, I will try to read them when I have more free time.  Just try to be a bit more thoughtful...then I'm sure Dave will allow you to continue here.  He has a generous spirt and a philosophy of inclusiveness, but you have to do your part, k? 

    Posted by a d on 08/25/2009 @ 06:06PM PT

  38. Alex Godoy

    I am sorry to tell you Ana, that It has never being painful for me being an outsider. I have never had a hard time in this country. I have never seen racism, bigotry or whatever towards me. I've been in the most remote wonderful small towns in the deep south, and people couldn't be warmer. The greatest people I've ever met in my life, as I am sure all Americans are all accross this nation. Is it because I am White? I don't think so; even though I've been able to almost completely get rid of the accent, yearas ago I still had a strong one and never saw any type of hostile attitude towards me. Even more, when I tell people that I had the honor to come to this nation and become an American, the with interest and admiration as where I was from. Why? because all goes on how you present yourself; your self esteem, self confidence, culture, knowledge. Racism and all that crap are cheap excuses; I've always had great jobs, awesome medical coverage, all because I cultivate myself. I educate myself every day, and try to be a better American for this country and its people. There is no need to work as a mule when you are valuable. If you have the need for that, well, something is wrong with the individual because this country does not close doors o anybody. They should blame themselves, not the victim.

    So one last thing, I don't have a clue why you are asking me to have respect, if in any moment I have never said anything other than the truth. If you don't believe it, you should go for a few days to places like Miami or L.A.

    I am the one who now ask for respect, and I do so representing The United States of America and its people. The law will be respected here. period. The culture, the language, traditions and values, will be respected. The flag, is untouchable. This country is my dream, I love it, and I will defend it til death. My piece of land will always have the American flag, and I will sit on the side with my shotgun with the rights my constitution grant me and the duty as a citizen to defend it. This forum will go forever, this issue will go forever, but the idiosyncrasy of Americans won't change. Many things can be tolerated, many agreements can be reached, but there are core issues that are non-negotiable. What happened to Americans crossing into north korea? What happened to Americans crossing into Iran? should we act the same way? ironically, we should according to our laws. However, for DECADES we have not enforced those rules; yet, people keep asking and pushing for more. When will this stop?? We are sick of it.

    Posted by Alex Godoy on 08/25/2009 @ 07:43PM PT

  39. Dave Bennion

    have you ever seen the movie "Borat"?

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/25/2009 @ 08:12PM PT

  40. Gary Stein

    Well ana lisa, perhaps the first thing you saw this evening was the e-mail i sent this morning to the entire Fort Worth city council (and Charles Krauthammer, Kathyln Parker, you and about 40 other various contacts including the White House; the WH is my favorite, always enjoy the automated response back)

    What can I say?  I feel all this stuff is conected.  Here's my posting on the gay side of the blog a little while ago.

    ...................................................................

    Chris, was just going to comment on thread when I saw your request in my e-mail.  This is what I've been up to this morning: e-mailed entire fort worth city council and the cowardly police dept. Two assumptions are in order maybe 1) i read about the situation and where it stood in June. 2) and you and I can agree this was pretty much a rogue incident and that Stonewall- back in the day - revealed the typical police dept., not the exception.

    Anyway here's two hours worth of work this morning (including time with my computer that wouldn't load and watching more you tubes...(not the musical variety type like I enjoy.)"

    "I think this is the message my computer got hung up on and I couldn’t send to the gay police officer on you tube, and then the article that contained all the e-mail addresses….…I was complimenting gays fighting spirit on the change.org  blog and mentioned Stonewall and a gay man, responding to my comment, mentioned Fort Worth.  Saw the other video and this.  You did an excellent job in front of the camera in 2nd video explaining your personality quirks (an asset).  Check out my web site Stein for Governor, we have a lot in common.  Going to e-mail the Fort Worth and mention how “bad press gets around.”

    http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archives/2009/06/30/fort-worth-police-chief-that-faggot-had-it-coming

    and here's the you tube I think my comment did get added to.  Who the hell knows?  can’t keep track and head starts to spin. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PScswWSOas0&NR=1

     

    (Chris)..and here’s message I e-mailed to neanderthals in Fort Worth:"  Do the right thing!  are you guys kidding in this day and age; this is why people are disgusted with civil servant high jinks and things (misdeeds) being swept under the rugs.

    I’m one little man but I hope you got hundreds of e-mails from small folk like me trying to put bureaucrats like you on notice.  For your perusal (and maybe amusement?), my web site is http://www.steinforgovernor.com/Come_Fly_With__Me.html

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/26/2009 @ 08:36AM PT

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/26/2009 @ 08:59AM PT

  41. Mr. Godoy,

    This past weekend, I was going over the transcripts of the murder trial of Julio Maldonado and Denis Calderon (Dave blogged about it in a recent post).  Thirteen years ago, these men were the victims of a hate crime when they attacked by a racist white mob (20 to 30 people against two men).  The principle assailant died at the scene of natural causes and the pair was later charged with murder.  Eventually, they were both acquitted of the murder charges by all twelve members of the jury.  However, because of a legal technicality, they were sent back to prison and are due to be deported to Peru as soon as they are released. Now, these men have lived in the U.S. almost their entire lives – that is, since they were toddlers. This is just one case, but what you may not realize is that injustices like this happen every day in America. As an immigration attorney, Dave could tell you of other stories, I’m sure.  The reason you’re not aware of these stories is because it generally happens to people of color.  And frankly you don’t have to be aware because it doesn’t affect you personally, does it?  But that doesn’t mean it isn’t happening.

    Now, the part of the trial that struck me most was probably the most boring. It was right at the start of the trial when the judge was delivering instructions to the jury. And the reason it made such an impression is that I realized all the pains the judge was going to be sure the jury would come to a fair and impartial decision. She didn’t want them to go into that courtroom with all the biases that most of us have and jump to a snap conclusion before hearing all the evidence.  Then, one of the defense attorneys stood up and delivered the opening statement, and he cautioned the jury in similar terms.  Here’s what he said:

    “I don’t know if you do it, but I sometimes let my brain run too quickly and I’ll size up three facts and come to a conclusion, then a week later I’m very sorry.  All I’m asking you to do is keep an open mind.  Listen to all the witnesses to see whether the Commonwealth proves any of the elements of these charges.”

    As I mentioned, we all have biases of one sort or another and judges are aware of this; attorneys are aware of this.  So, the jury charge is a way of safeguarding against people’s hidden biases.  And we all have prejudices that sometimes we are not even aware we have. So, when you refer undocumented immigrants as criminals, this is one of those biases, in my humble opinion. Tell me, what have they been convicted of?  Most of my Latino students have never been convicted in a court of law.  They are INNOCENT until proven guilty. So please don’t refer to them as criminals.  That is a injustice; that is ignorance and that is uncalled for! If you have no proof of a conviction, you are not entitled to call people criminals.

    Now, you made a statement about Latinos is biased because it is so sweeping and so demonstrably untrue.  You said that Latinos do not care to learn English and are just here to But if you ever bothered to read some of the stories about the DREAMers on this blog, you would see that many of them are honor students, volunteers in their community and hard workers.  Most have NEVER been in trouble with the law, except for a civil violation.    So, please, Mr. Godoy, check your prejudices at the door.  We are not asking for much from your side: just a fair and impartial hearing.  Thank you. 

    Posted by a d on 08/26/2009 @ 05:39PM PT

  42. I say this respectfully...please take the time to educate yourself:

    http://www.immigrantslist.org/pages/myths_vs_facts

    Posted by a d on 08/26/2009 @ 06:05PM PT

  43. Gary Stein

    I'm messing the continuum of the threads again I see.  It's partly the fault of the format.  I got to wind "this" down anyway, I'm such a pain in the butt.  I bet that cop on you tube (if anybody bothered clicking on it) appreciated me.  I see a lot of myself in that guy.

    I wonder what's on you tube if you look up Immigration and Customs Enforcement?

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/26/2009 @ 07:26PM PT

  44. Gary Stein

    a whole slew

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYwG6Z6NvsA

    maybe some of you have put the same links in... and I didn't click on?  is that possible ana?  if so then I'm really a big stupid bore and I'll take a self imposed holiday for a while.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/26/2009 @ 07:38PM PT

  45. Kurt Thialfad

    So, when you refer undocumented immigrants as criminals, this is one of those biases, in my humble opinion. Tell me, what have they been convicted of?

    Alex has it right they have committed a crime by definition, regardless of whether or not a jury has convicted them.  

    Posted by Kurt Thialfad on 08/26/2009 @ 09:19PM PT

  46. Dave Bennion

    Not.  Visa overstay is a civil violation, 40% of undocumented immigrants in the U.S.  You are lumping all undocumented immigrants together in ignorance of the actual laws that apply.  You've heard this before, you repeatedly choose to propagate misinformation because you think you won't be called on it.

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/26/2009 @ 09:34PM PT

  47. Gary Stein

     

    That’s one white poker chip for Mr. Benion for the clarification on visa overstays and one red chip for Mr. Godoy for this sentence in a thread I missed from a few days ago  “This forum will go forever, this issue will go forever, but the idiosyncrasy of Americans won't change. Many things can be tolerated, many agreements can be reached, but there are core issues that are non-negotiable”

     I’m just about ready to go into “limp home mode” in these critical two months before the election- you know, the one for governor where I just needed a token 2% or so and we would have gotten some nice real attention- for say- the very simple  concept of issuing drivers licenses to our “undocumenteds.”   It might actually save lives, it would definitely eliminate the potential every one of us has to be made destitute in the blink of an eye.  And in case nobody knows,  “limp home”  is a feature in luxury cars that gets the owner back home in 1st gear even after a major systems failure.

    And never mind Mr. Godoy!  Mr. Lindley has it right when he asks me whether I realize there’s an agenda here.  Maybe the pro-immigrant cause doesn’t want to tidy up this drivers license mess too quickly and maybe "pro-immigrant" really is code for "pro-immigration" as in “open borders”

    And am I nuts or is Mr. Godoys other contribution, the one from last night missing?  It’s in my e-mail this morning but I can’t find it in the story.  This is part of what he said, I’m quoting from my e-amil, “ Remember that funding is not coming from the government; it is coming from us; from our taxes; and I am sorry to tell you that I work and earn money for me, not for others. Anybody is free to give millions in charity if they wanted, but nobody, and certainly not the government, can force me to pay for others.” 

     The punk running for Governor has repeated over and over that I think all this back and forth is like the old admonition  “how many angels can you fit on the head of a pin” Over on the gay issues side of this blog there was this riposte waiting to greet me this morning in my e-mail as well. “ Ok mr. marshall but what did the goats for women have to do with homosexuals?”  And...Yeah, unfortunatly, women were treated as cattle back then. posted by Thomas McHugh  ( I can’t find that comment added to that story either.  Is there major censorship going on here?  That could open up a whole other can of worms.)  And sorry to drag your name over to here, Mr. McHugh, your picture is proudly posted as a friend on my profile page.

    My point is nothing ever gets settled adequately this way.  I posted a thread over on the gay side stating that I sent a bunch of e-mails out; critical of the Fort Worth city council and police department,  and that I also posted kind words on You-tube to a gay cop from San Francisco who was outraged about police brutality in a Fort Worth gay bar last June-  and it’s as if I don’t exist over there. 

    Here’s my prediction where, little Stein for Governor is going, and where amnesty is heading.  I finish 8 out of a field of 12 instead of 4th.  Amnesty gets passed next year over much objection, the Obama administration is spent after winning the amnesty fight and barely getting any reforms on health care- but he wins re-election thanks to a surge in Hispanic registrations- but his 2nd term is a waste- all his capital is gone.   Beto never gets the hell out of Mexico, the wall is finished and Mexico sinks deeper into stagnation and chaos.  The amnsesty card which we could have used to pressure Mexico, in the form of a boycott- is history- I’m history.

    p.s. Because I had no momentum  I’m left to explain why my slogan for Ocean County, NJ was “Something Stupid” and how did I ever expect voters in one county to know I picked a different Sinatra tune, one for each county in the state.  They were left thinking I was nuts and voted for some other guy.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bu8UF9szrlE&feature=related  this lovely lady at least sent me a thank you note. (yes, yes I know someone very important here has been very kind and patient with me)

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 06:41AM PT

  48. Gary Stein

     ana lisa, I still haven’t told you what the woman who owned the Mexican restaurant had to say about boycotts etc?

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 06:44AM PT

  49. Kurt Thialfad

    Visa overstay is a civil violation

    Well, murder is a  civil violation, too.  Remember the OJ trial? Divorce is a civil affair.  Litigation is the scope of the civil courts.

    I find disingenuous your lawyerly twisting of the truth.

    Posted by Kurt Thialfad on 08/27/2009 @ 08:40AM PT

  50. Liquids Reign

    Visa overstay is a civil violation

     

    A visa Overstay is an Administrative Offence, it is NOT a Civil Offence, Progressives equate it to be that of or equal to a Civil Offence. It is the Federal Government against the immigrant not the State.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/27/2009 @ 12:26PM PT

  51. I am NOT a lawyer, Kurt, so there was no "lawyerly twisting of the truth" on my part. But to the best of my knowledge, civil violations generally involve claims for damages (i.e. compensation in dollars).  The crime of murder is a criminal violation, unless someone is suing for loss of consortium or something like that (the loss of the  support of a spouse, etc.).  But I have forgotten what little I picked up from that paralegal course on Tort claims.  Fortunately, we have an honest-to-goodness lawyer on board -- one who is well versed in immigration law. So, why don't you ask him before you make ridiculous assumptions?  That is, unless you are both so full of yourselves that you think you know it all.  (However, I'm guessing that he may be a caught up with work today.) 

    Posted by a d on 08/27/2009 @ 03:33PM PT

  52. Correction: The assailant in the Maldonado case did not die at the scene. His heart stopped and he was in a coma for two years before he died.  It was later determined that he died of natural causes.  My error.

    Posted by a d on 08/27/2009 @ 03:39PM PT

  53. Liquids Reign

    That is, unless you are both so full of yourselves that you think you know it all.

    Dave is the one which left the comment that was responded to. Look above:

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/26/2009 @ 09:34PM PT

     

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/27/2009 @ 05:27PM PT

  54. I was the one who originally stated that it was a civil violation, but if Kurt really thinks he can argue with an immigration attorney, he is one dumb little bunny. 

    Posted by a d on 08/27/2009 @ 05:57PM PT

  55. Liquids Reign

    Then in that case, both you and Dave are incorrect in stating that it is a "civil violation" to overstay a visa.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/27/2009 @ 06:03PM PT

  56. Sorry Kurt, I am pretty stressed out this week (first week of school).  I guess that's why I am reverting to my smartass self when I promised Dave I would maintain a positive tone (not that he called me on it or anything).  So I do apologize for calling you a 'dumb bunny.'  I didn't mean it...just frustration.  Mea culpa.

    Posted by a d on 08/27/2009 @ 06:06PM PT

  57. Liquids Reign

    Your exact quote was: Most have NEVER been in trouble with the law, except for a civil violation.

    Dave's exact quote was: Visa overstay is a civil violation

    Which is what was italicized by both Kurt and myself. Now as for your "plausible distinction" claim of Most of my Latino students have never been convicted in a court of law.  They are INNOCENT until proven guilty. So please don’t refer to them as criminals.  That is a injustice; that is ignorance and that is uncalled for! If you have no proof of a conviction, you are not entitled to call people criminals. You are correct up to the point in which they do have to prove their status, in which case if they can not prove their status, i.e. for a drivers license, vehicle code infractions, or any other infraction for which they are required to prove their status, then they become "deportable aliens" and are considered to be in violation of immigration law which is a criminal offence, usually a class 4 Federal Misdemeanor.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/27/2009 @ 06:17PM PT

  58. However, I do have to laugh some folks who have never set foot in a law school, yet think they can argue the law in a blog.  Thanks for the giggle!

    Posted by a d on 08/27/2009 @ 06:22PM PT

  59. Liquids Reign

    Giggle?? Your daddy is a lawyer, prove what I have said to be incorrect. Dave can attempt, too. Even your own side, the groups you use to justify your mis-quoted statements agree with me, if you do the copy and paste correctly from them.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/27/2009 @ 06:30PM PT

  60. Liquids Reign

    Removal proceedings are civil in nature, and the extensive constitutional safeguards attending criminal proceedings do not apply. INS v. Lopez-Mendoza, 468 U.S. 1032, 1038 (1984); United States v. Aguirre-Tello, 353 F.3d 1199, 1204 (10th Cir. 2004) (en banc). Rather, "the procedural safeguards are minimal because aliens do not have a constitutional right to enter or remain in the United States." Aguilera v. Kirkpatrick, 241 F.3d 1286, 1292 (10th Cir. 2001). Therefore, when facing removal, aliens are entitled only to procedural due process, which provides "the opportunity to be heard at `a meaningful time and in a meaningful manner.'" (in front of an Immigration Judge) de la Llana-Castellon v. INS, 16 F.3d 1093, 1096 (10th Cir. 1994) (quoting Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319, 333 (1976))

    I have given this to you before Analisa, you have yet to refute any of it. Maybe you should do some research before making such bold statements that are factually incorrect.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 08/27/2009 @ 07:01PM PT

  61. Arvida Brustad

    This is in reply to Analisa...you are not Latina/White...you are either Latina/European American or...you are Brown/White.  You must learn to not mix apples and oranges...if you refer to European Americans as White then the Latina is Brown...just like the African Americans are Black.  I am offended when educated individuals as yourself do not understand the difference.  Thank you.

    Posted by Arvida Brustad on 08/31/2009 @ 02:10PM PT

  62. Reply to thread
  63. Chris Marshall

    Because they combined the UAFA with this reform bill I hope people can understand that around 40,000 families livelihoods are at stake. These are couples that have struggled under the discriminatory policies of DOMA for years, some having to live past their visa to stay with the spouses/partners, and children. Having to feel the pain of separation, which is a pain far worse than a loss, I plead with people to see this issue as a human right; not as an right for illegal immigrants to get a free pass.

    For those who wish to correct me and tell me to put Ruben on the lottery system I am saddened to inform you that the waiting period just to get into the lottery is eight years. If he is not one of the 50,000 selected he has to wait another two years. With this economic crisis we are in, when he comes to settle down here with me he wishes to become a state police officer. If he is laid off he will lose his visa and will be deported back to Finland. Even if we get married this still applies, and even if DOMA is repealed this still applies in the state where I am getting my degree in. I shouldn't have to give up my education, my career goals and my life to become a forensic pathologist, so I can be with the person one who saved my life and brought it meaning. I shouldn't have to leave my home country, that I am proud to be a part of, just to be with the person I love.

    There is more at stake here than many realize. Please dont support the pain of seperation that Ruben and I, and the 40,000 other couples have to face because of the discriminatory immigration policies of the US.

    Sincerely

    Chris Marshall

    Posted by Chris Marshall on 08/23/2009 @ 08:01PM PT

  64. Dave Bennion

    i don't know whether the question of whether piecemeal or CIR is better is the most useful question.  i think a more useful question is: how can we engage local communities in the different issue campaigns (UAFA, DREAM, deported veterans, family separation, etc.), and how can we collaborate better across those issue campaigns?  i'd be happy to hear your thoughts on this.

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/23/2009 @ 08:54PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  65. Gary Stein

    Chris Marshall what's going on over on the other blog?  You've been awfully quiet lately and we're blood brothers now.  I just posted this mysterious comment below over there.  Does it stay for more then a few minutes?  Or has the censor gone to bed for the night?

    Here's the comment.  I also pasted another bloggers comment that got caught up in the "sweap"

     

    This precious comment was in my in box this afternoon and tonight and until I decide to delete it.  Things have a way of disappearing all of a sudden.  “Odd...I see the post - but Juniper's original posts have disappeared, for some reason.”
    posted by Mattz HL

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eh9WayN7R-s&feature=related am I banned?  Where are all my earlier comments?  Stay on topic stupid (talking to myself) or you land in jail.

     Dat ol' man river
    He must know somethin'
    But don't say nuthin',

    Let me go way from the mississippi
    Let me go way from the white man boss
    Show me that stream called the river jordan
    Thats the old stream that I long to cross.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 09:18PM PT

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 09:26PM PT

  66. Gary Stein

    signed the Petition Pass the Employment Non-Discrimination Act 1 minute ago    Hide

    that's me signing a petition for Chris Marshall seconds after my thread posted.  I had no idea my brother and i where send letters simultaneously.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h_klQNiYhNA  What can I say, I’m a frustrated disk jockey.   This song is beautiful.

      I'm doing a little heavy lifting over there and I get banned for my troubles.  Liquid Reigns what's your take?  and ana lisa, the lady, the Mexican restaurant?  I'm leaving soon, this sight is missing in the fun department.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 09:38PM PT

  67. Reply to thread
  68. Mark  Lindley

      Why does someone have to live here pass their visa?    Couldn't they renew it before it expired?  Just asking.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/26/2009 @ 09:50AM PT

  69. Gary Stein

    some one by the name of Juniper and maybe even me (?) has been banned over at the gay rights side.  if that's the case the hypocrisy and stupidity is amazing..............this is a blog! what the heck is everybody so afraid of?  if "we're asking all the people on "the outside" world to help make the world a better place, how can this site be intolerant.  words, it's only words.  which brings to mind folks another you tube wizzing around inside my cabesa.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ISil7IHzxc

    that's from 1986.  How about that guy from the Washington Times?  does he look stupid? does he over react?  would he be for immigration reform in 2009?  let people have their say!!!!  let them look bad if that's what they do- look bad.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 02:01PM PT

  70. Reply to thread
  71. Gary Stein

    so far so good i'm still here (my thread hasn't disappeared) and i'm heading out the door and i love you dave benion.  but the gay side of the blog?  what's up?  i didn't say anything inflammatory or anti gay, quite the opposite.  juniper did.  what did i mess up the flow of the threads?

    change. org of all places!  where we are supposed to be concerned about the tyranny of the mob (the majority).  go figure!

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/27/2009 @ 02:19PM PT

  72. Mark  Lindley

    Has anyone else noticed that the comments referenced in the right hand column on the main page do not always appear under that topic when you click them on?    Are they being held for moderation?    I am just curious as I have seen this so often in here.  Even those who hold the majority view seem to have their replies held in limbo also.   What's up?

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/31/2009 @ 03:11PM PT

  73. Mark  Lindley

    Mine seem to get posted right away.   Thank you very much!

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/31/2009 @ 03:17PM PT

  74. Alex Godoy

    In reply to Arvida,

    I learned English listening country music. I was tought by my parents, that when you go to someone elses house, you respect their place and act like they do.

    Mr. Bennion is right with the difference in crime and civil violation. However, that is only a burocratic technical issue. In the values and principles of Americans, If somebody enter my house by force, or somebody that I allow to pass through my hallway one time and decides to stay there forever by force, pay exactly the same consequences. Self defense using resources provided in the second amendment of the constitution.

    We will not pay for people that is not mentally skilled enough to respect the country and learn English by themselves, and we will not pay to fund a marxist medical system.

    Posted by Alex Godoy on 08/31/2009 @ 03:26PM PT

  75. Thomas Porter

    Analisa, lol you're not of "mixed race". There are three (3) races, Negroid, Mongoloid, Caucasoid.

    "Hispanic" or"Latina" are *ethnic groups* not races!

    That woud be like me of Irish Heratage trying to call myself a differant "race" by referring to myself as, "Celtic."

    Apples and oranges.

    Posted by Thomas Porter on 09/14/2009 @ 11:57PM PT

  76. Reply to thread

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.