Immigration

All-White Florida Jury Sanctions Private Deportations by Hospital

Published July 27, 2009 @ 10:32PM PT

Great job in voir dire, defendants' attorneys.  You succeeded in bleaching the jury.

A Mayan Indian from the highlands of Guatemala, Mr. Jiménez paid a smuggler to transport him to the United States about a decade ago so he could work as a gardener and send money home to his wife and two sons. He had been living in Stuart with Mr. Gaspar for just under a year when a drunken driver in a stolen vehicle plowed into his car in the winter of 2000.

Now 37, Mr. Jiménez, who cannot walk and has the mental age of a child, lives in a one-room house in a remote village, tended by his elderly mother. He is largely confined to his bed and suffers from routine seizures. When The Times visited him last summer, he had not received medical care for over five years.

In Florida, Martin Memorial, a nonprofit hospital, spent $1.5 million to care for Mr. Jiménez. The costs especially mounted because of a conundrum faced by the hospital. As a condition of receiving Medicaid and Medicare money, the hospital was required to care for Mr. Jiménez until it could properly discharge him under federal law.

That meant discharging Mr. Jiménez into a skilled nursing home, but the hospital could not find one willing to accept an uninsured illegal immigrant. So it kept Mr. Jiménez as a boarder until, in 2003, a state judge gave the hospital permission to send him back to Guatemala.

Martin Memorial's staff should be proud to work at a hospital that finds creative ways to circumvent federal regulations to send sick patients to their death abroad.  Congressional Republicans should be proud to be blocking reform to both the broken immigration and health care systems that ensure these private deportations will be repeated.  Stuart's white jurors should be proud for sticking it to the low-income Guatemalans who clean their bathrooms and prepare their food.  And for being white, I guess.

This is a result in which everyone involved can take pride!

[Image: Josh Haner/The New York Times]

Share this Post

Related Posts

Comments (83)

  1. Mark  Lindley

    So bottom line is that you think this country has no right to enforce its immigration laws or deport anyone?   And we should bear these huge medical expenses incurred by those in our country illegally such as this man?

    I can't imagine anyone leaviing their family for that amount of time for any reason whatsoever.   Love, companioniiship and nurturing one's spouse and children should take priority over economics.   I don't understand that kind of mindset at all.    And no, starvation I am sure wasn't part of the equasion.

     

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 07/28/2009 @ 06:55AM PT

  2. elliot  Foley III

    I didn't realize he was dead Dave?

    So you are saying that a jury comprised of "wise Latina women with the richness of their experiences" would have come to a different conclusion than a jury of white men?

     

     

    Posted by elliot Foley III on 07/28/2009 @ 01:53PM PT

  3. Wire Paladin

    Why waste the expense of a jury on this nonsense? 

    Posted by Wire Paladin on 07/30/2009 @ 01:58AM PT

  4. Gary Stein

    Dave, an “undocumented”  Mexican family I know who lives not far from me has to care for a quadriplegic and former bread winner of the family, who was riding on the back of a “sanitation” truck when an “uninsured motorist” side swiped the back of the vehicle and paralyzed him.  He, the undocumented, was on the books so he’s surviving on the payout from the company’s insurance, that entire amount which was then deducted from anything he was entitled to from the state (not much)…………and the uninsured driver, a young white male driving his MOTHERS car, and needless to say, that would make at least 2 generations of US “citizens,” got off with a traffic ticket!

    He was married, but now he is divorced and living with his brother, sister in-law and their 3 children in a very small house that they all rent on a first floor.  If you drive by the house you’ll see the ramp.  I don’t ask what happened to Maria, but I never would have imagined she’d leave.  When he was in a coma she sat by his swollen body for weeks.  Beto and I brought some of the family members along with us when we visited them in the hospital a few times.  It’s been about 3 years and I forget the name of that rehab. hospital in Camden not far from the Ben Franklin bridge.  Back in those days I presumptively thought one, he’d at least be set for life, that’s a laugh now, and two, he’d be better off when he returned to Mexico (and unlike Beto, he never learned a word of English, and unlike my tragic acquaintance’s brother and his wife)------that is until I visited Mexico.  

    Mr. Lindley thinks I take one or two anecdotes and then make broad judgements about immigration reform.  Wire Paladin, I don't know whether or not he's in "character" or not.  We had our "show down' already.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 05:10AM PT

  5. Gary Stein

    Dave, an “undocumented”  Mexican family I know who lives not far from me has to care for a quadriplegic and former bread winner of the family, who was riding on the back of a “sanitation” truck when an “uninsured motorist” side swiped the back of the vehicle and paralyzed him.  He, the undocumented, was on the books so he’s surviving on the payout from the company’s insurance, that entire amount which was then deducted from anything he was entitled to from the state (not much)…………and the uninsured driver, a young white male driving his MOTHERS car, and needless to say, that would make at least 2 generations of US “citizens,” got off with a traffic ticket!

    He was married, but now he is divorced and living with his brother, sister in-law and their 3 children in a very small house that they all rent on a first floor.  If you drive by the house you’ll see the ramp.  I don’t ask what happened to Maria, but I never would have imagined she’d leave.  When he was in a coma she sat by his swollen body for weeks.  Beto and I brought some of the family members along with us when we visited them in the hospital a few times.  It’s been about 3 years and I forget the name of that rehab. hospital in Camden not far from the Ben Franklin bridge.  Back in those days I presumptively thought one, he’d at least be set for life, that’s a laugh now, and two, he’d be better off when he returned to Mexico (and unlike Beto, he never learned a word of English, and unlike my tragic acquaintance’s brother and his wife)------that is until I visited Mexico.  

    Mr. Lindley thinks I take one or two anecdotes and then make broad judgements about immigration reform.  Wire Paladin, I don't know whether or not he's in "character" or not.  We had our "show down' already.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 05:10AM PT

  6. Gary Stein

    How does it get added twice?

    By the way, the little boy lives with the father and the relatives.  The last time I saw Palone was when I was gathering signatures to run for you know what, on car cruise night in Hammonton.  We waved at each other.  The boy was walking next to his father in the wheel chair.  The former soccer player and former very happy person who went through years of hell but now seems to be better, probably for the sake of his son.  It was dicey for awhile.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 05:16AM PT

  7. Luis  Ramos

    The main reason he was deported back to his country was because he was caosting the hospital millions and noone was paying for his treatment. On top of that he was an illegal immigrant. Where was his loved ones when he needed them?

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 07/30/2009 @ 06:11AM PT

  8. Martin Memorial's staff should be proud to work at a hospital that finds creative ways to circumvent federal regulations to send sick patients to their death abroad.  Congressional Republicans should be proud to be blocking reform to both the broken immigration and health care systems that ensure these private deportations will be repeated.  Stuart's white jurors should be proud for sticking it to the low-income Guatemalans who clean their bathrooms and prepare their food.  And for being white, I guess.

    This is a result in which everyone involved can take pride!

    Word, hombre!

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 09:59AM PT

  9. Gary Stein

    are we not communicating anymore?

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 11:31AM PT

  10. ah Gary, you are a quixotic dreamer, hombre -- something I can appreciate.  But I must tell you: you're tilting at windmills here.  At any rate, I doubt  that you will be convince Dave or any of the rest of us to go down to Mexico with you.  You need to learn the art of listening to your would-be constituents...this is what Obama did and why he was so successful.  But I apologize for my bad humor the other day.  Yes, we are still communicating. So, tell me, Gary, what is your view of these 287(g) agreements?

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 11:46AM PT

  11. Gary Stein

    Has Obama been successful with health care.  Answer no.  Do you think he's going to tackle immigration reform next after expending all that political capital?   I doubt it, not when the sides are so polarized.  We both watched the same Basso you-tube didn't we.  I thought it had 6 million hits, correction it was 7 million.

    Why wouldn't Dave want to become more familiar with his subject?

    Apology accepted concerning other day.  By the way you'd never know there was anything wrong health wise with my nomination for Leiutenent Governor by looking at her.  She looks strong as a bull.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 12:09PM PT

  12. Gary Stein

    Delegation of Immigration Authority Section 287(g) Immigration and Nationality Act. A Law Enforcement Partnership. ICE ACCESS (Agreements of Cooperation in ...
    www.ice.gov/partners/287g/Section287_g.htm

    I love ICE, was that the old INS?  What do you think I think of ICE?  Bunch of idiots!

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 12:14PM PT

  13. That's a non-answer Gary.  I asked your opinion of the 287(g) agreements.  Now, tell me truthfully...did you just google it because you're not even sure what it is?  Do you understand why it matters to the Latino/immigrant community?  And are you saying that you love ICE, the same agency that is rounding up and deporting people like your best friend Beto?  Is that what you're telling me?

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 01:10PM PT

  14. Gary Stein

    oh my god, ana lisa, yes I googled but yes I pretty much new what i'd find.  oh, my god, the last half of my comment was I called ICE a "bunch of idiots!"

    ana lisa, I had a web site last year, my friend had the access because I was and still am a computer moron, so it needs to be cleaned up I couldn't bother him after first draft. The Yokel News, no need to type the www.  com.  Go to it 3rd page to see how i feel about ICE.  The first page is me pretending to be losing it.  That was meant to be, oh never mind, please just go there.  Lot's of pictures of Mexico too.  I wish I'd seen your comment earlier, will be here till about 5pm.  I do like talking to you, besides you look very cute, and me and Wire Paladin might be heading for a High Noon.  Why won't Mr. Bennion want to go to Mexico with me, groups go all over the world all the time.   Does he completely misunderstand me too?

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 01:40PM PT

  15. Yes, I see where you called ICE "a bunch of idiots."  Sorry, I got a little emotional and didn't hear what you were saying.  I have no idea what Mr. Bennion thinks about your proposal or what he will do.  I just know how it strikes me. If you want to go off on a quixotic quest by yourself, that's fine.  Send me a postcard.  But I've gone to a lot of trouble to respond to your platform, without getting any answers to my questions.  Take 287(g) for example...I still don't know where you stand on this.  I don't have a sense that you're in touch with the concerns of the Latin@/ immigrant community.  I have the feeling you're just off in the clouds somewhere, oblivious to our concerns.  Forgive me, but could it be that you're running for office in order to escape some issues you can't face at home?  A lot of men do this.  I know my boyfriend gets deeply involved in some major project when he's scared to face emotional issues.  I know that's a little personal so you don't have to answer that.  I just put it out there as something for you to think about.  You appear to have a lot going on in your life right now, just gathering from what you told me.  But we can continue the discussion if you like.

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 02:25PM PT

  16. Sorry, I didn't mean to psychoanalyze you.  It's just something I'm wondering about (I'm a fiction writer, so I'm genuinely curious about people's motivations).  And you mentioned that your wife was mad at you.  Anyway, you really don't have to answer me. It's personal and I probably shouldn't have asked you that.

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 02:40PM PT

  17. Gary Stein

    Home for the night.  Goodness you think I'd be afraid to answer a personal question?  Did you go to the yokel news?  Is there not a picture of me standing in my boxer shorts wearing a sport jacket for that nights congressional debate, and me announcing to the world that the threads where purchased at the Red, White and Blue Thrift store?  Was there not an issue titled the Divorce Issue (there were actually two Div. Issue's only posted one)?  What was your question, I forgot?

    There's too much to discuss in one thread.  Your a writer?  Write a screen play about me.  Did you read the one thread to Dave where I said Ben Stiller could play me, or do you skim a little bit like I confessed to doing? After the fiasco of me running for congress last year do you think I think I'm going anywhere with this?  It's all about getting one reporter to go to Mexico, and maybe things would then fall into place helping Beto and maybe me (make a little money i.e. screen play). E-mails didn't work when I came back from the first visit, so I ran for congress and now Governor, what the heck after all this I'm entitled to think about a few sheckles (maybe you'll see me at Cannes, France). The idealism fell by the wayside about 2 months  (July) into last years congressional silliness.   I have 3 more months left this year to be a pain in the ass. The point is some good could come out of it!!!  Mr. Bennion is going to regret not going with me if I ever do get a group together.  Why wouldn't anyone interested in immigration concerns not take me up on the offer.  Beto is the perfect guide.  I'll get us all from the Mexico City airport to his home town in one piece, and then you'll see exotic Mexico like few Americans have seen it- when Beto takes over.  Ask me about the places we could visit. Did you know I invited Mr. Lindley?  He's like you, he wants to argue policy minutia.  I'm the only one expected to answer half a dozen questions in one thread.  It's hard to do like this. 

    287g, isn't it enough that I consider ICE to be like the Gestapo, and I'm telling you your not going to get your way with people like Mr. lindley and my congressman opposing you.  And my congressman is a slick one, he's all for sounding like an environmentalist but his position on amnesty- he brags he'd be the first one to vote against it.  What the heck, don't you see why a boycott Mexico, secure the border, and amnesty in combination would work?  A half a loaf.  I could ask Mr. Lindley the same question.  It needed to originate from the Hispanics and their friends, us (I've just about given up).  And starvation in Mexico from a 2-3 month boycott?  I don't think so.  And a boycott by definition is about sacrifice.  And speaking of avoiding the question.  Wouldn't a boycott send a message about our not tolerating the corruption that forces their people to flee in the first place. And answer this.  Are you for open borders?

    How's that for a stream of consciousness?  And is it possible I made short work of Mr. Wire Palidan this morning.  Where is he.  Did you know he has a web site like me.  Did you see his last comment to Mellisa.  He was in full role mode.  The girl is only 18 years old.

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 09:12PM PT

  18. Gary Stein

    correction- not your a writer, you're a writer?

    how about a little music?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9U6URQSF6U

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 09:18PM PT

  19. Oh, I've already tried my hand at writing a screenplay.  It was god-awful. he,he. But writing is rewriting, as they say...and I do get better with revision.  Maybe someday I'll get up the courage to revisit that piece.  I will say this...you would make a great character for a screenplay, Gary. Very colorful. :-)

    Posted by a d on 07/31/2009 @ 04:21PM PT

  20. Nice choice, Gary. :-)  You know one of my pseudonyms at theWrit.org was Astrud the Mute Chanteuse (after Astrud Gilberto).

    Posted by a d on 07/31/2009 @ 05:07PM PT

  21. Gary Stein

    am i flattering myself too much when I say I think my contentious middle of the road suggestions and the smart alleck threads revives the dialogue just when you think it's done.  i'm a shy guy off the internet but blogging is like acting and my Mexico experiences is like Superman and krypton, or was that what took away his power?  I had a long wknd. I could look that up.  I knew you'd like Gilberto.  I actually have this song on an album and I've loved it for years.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By4GrrDyKNc

    ana lisa, try and find the you tube where she's on Italian tv.  I can't think of the name of song, windy is playing in background.  it might even be on my web site?

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/01/2009 @ 06:02PM PT

  22. okay, I'll look for it...my mother is a big fan of Gilberto. You know, Gary, from what I've seen, you have a better imagination than any real campaign sense. I was thinking that if you write a good script, you would stand to make more money than your campaign for Governor (which will probably just break the bank and piss off your wife). You've got a great story here with a wonderful protagonist -- namely you and your quixotic longing for recognition at any cost. What do you think about that suggestion? 

    btw, you can find some great (free) screenwriting software here:

     http://celtx.com/

    Posted by a d on 08/01/2009 @ 07:13PM PT

  23. Reply to thread
  24. Mark  Lindley

    We cannot afford to care for foreign nationals.  We can hardly take care of our own citizen's medical needs and many of our citizens are uninsured.   Yes, I am all for healthcare reform but only if it means we will have good healthcare and that it will only be reserved for citizens or legal residents.  The only exception should be emergencies for those in our country illegally and then patch them up and send them home.   They are responsibility of their own countries, not ours.

    So if someone chooses to clean bathrooms or whatever without the right to work here , we should be obligated to care for them medically?    Let their crooked employer pay for their medical care then.   It wasn't honest Americans that hired them or asked to clean any bathroom or prepare any food.

    Race card pulling against white people duly noted yet again.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 07/30/2009 @ 10:41AM PT

  25. Gary Stein

     

    ana lisa I do skim the comments, and I expect anyone to read what I write?  Just saw Mr. Lindley’s comment. 

    “Race card pulling against white people duly noted yet again.”   

    That’s one small thumbs up for him, but nobody sees the value a middle ground position like mine.  Secure the border, grant amnesty across the board, and with Hispanics leading the way boycott Mexico; because Mexico is desirous of it and it is the one we share a border with and the one with the most numbers here.  When the rest of Central America sees how everyone is living so much better in Mexico after the corruption is hopefully stamped out (not 100%, not 90%, but say 60%) they’ll run their version of bad government out of town next.

     

    The alternative is for the 6 or 7 foreign policy makers on this sight, including me, to continue to fight amongst ourselves which has it’s own rewards.  It’s good clean fun.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 12:02PM PT

  26. Gary, I would like to repeat what I said to Mary, so that you have a better idea of where we're coming from (at the grassroots level, anyway):

    The amnesty issue is a non-starter, as far as I'm concerned. We are well aware that amnesty isn't even on the table right now. The trade-off appears to be between a strenuous and punitive "path to citizenship" in exchange for stepped-up enforcement measures. But this will only serve to perpetuate the the same problems as before, while solving very little that's wrong with the system. We are looking for sensible, humane reform, not just an amnesty or a "path to citizenship."

    I'm not sure that you really understand where we are coming from in the grassroots (not that we all think alike, but we share many of the same concerns). Any reform bill that is truly comprehensive should address the raids, private (for-profit) prisons, racial profiling and other issues of deep concern to immigrant communities. We are willing to compromise, however we do not wish to enter into a faustian bargain that criminalizes hard-working immigrant families while dangling the carrot of "amnesty" (or "path to citizenship") in front of our noses. Any reforms must be comprehensive and address the entire system which is broken.

    And I would drop the issue of a Mexican boycott altogether, because there's no support for it on either side.  Mexican migrants are not going to stop sending remittances to their families because some gringo tells them to, no matter what you think.

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 01:51PM PT

  27. Gary Stein

    "And I would drop the issue of a Mexican boycott altogether, because there's no support for it on either side.  Mexican migrants are not going to stop sending remittances to their families because some gringo tells them to, no matter what you think."

    you're right

    out the door, maybe we can discuss later.

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 01:59PM PT

  28. Luis  Ramos

    I was with you until you wanted amnesty for the illegals.

    Posted by Luis Ramos on 07/31/2009 @ 12:12PM PT

  29. Gary Stein

     

    I'm at a loss at this point.  Mr. Lindley thinks i want to have perpetual amnesty, and ana lisa is willing to wait till hell freezes over to get "comprehensive" something, I'm not sure what?  She knows how I feel about the raids, throw in racial profiling, I’m with her, but she's disingenuously not mentioning the border?  And she sometimes says I dodge questions.  Are you for open borders?

     If I want to meet with Mr. Benion on Monday, I probably should make an appointment with his secretary and expect to billed at the normal hourly rate.  My campaign war chest won’t accommodate that however.

    And I might have to fall back on another scheme to circulate my web site and get the message out, but either no one here is interested, since I did hint about it and better yet, I am running for chief executive of my state; or is it that no one reads completely what the other person is saying.  And if this site is going to ban people like it did Liquid Reins I might as well try sneaking back onto the Daily Kos where I was banned (over nonsense), there’s a lot more action and those bast…buggers are really sharp.

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 05:05PM PT

  30. Reply to thread
  31. Mark  Lindley

    I disagree, Gary.   Just because we share a border with Mexico or Canada for that matter and it is mostly Mexicans and other Latinos who have managed to circumvent our immigration laws is no reason to award them with amnesty and snub all the potential immigrants across this planet who have waited patiently for their turn.    Another reason we have quotas from diffferent ethnic groups is to stop colonization, non-assimilation and the changing of our traditional society by too many from just one ethnic group.   Get rid of your tunnel vision for this country and maybe you just might be a viable candidate in politics.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 07/30/2009 @ 01:27PM PT

  32. Gary Stein

    going out the door as I finish reading this, will get back.  ana lisa is really not reading anything I say very closely, you a little better.  The burden is on our side (hers) to convince your side because their is that little matter called "the law as it's on the books" they don't seem to understand.  I'll regret that last sentence because i really want to have a dialogue with her and Bennion.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 02:02PM PT

  33. Gary Stein

    after 5pm I'm late.  You did know I googled because I wanted you to know, right.  yes.  Didn't you ever try googling Wire Paladin?  It's a riot and pathetic all in one.    

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 02:06PM PT

  34. Gary Stein

    after 5pm I'm late.  You did know I googled because I wanted you to know, right.  yes.  Didn't you ever try googling Wire Paladin?  It's a riot and pathetic all in one.    

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/30/2009 @ 02:06PM PT

  35. Gary, you appear to be talking out of both sides of your mouth just like any other politician.  The burden is not us to please bullies and racists. You're the one running for office, not us.

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 03:21PM PT

  36. Dave Bennion

    Another reason we have quotas from diffferent ethnic groups is to stop colonization, non-assimilation and the changing of our traditional society by too many from just one ethnic group.

    There are no quotas for different ethnic groups.  Your reasoning is specious and unsupported.  Also you don't seem to know much about the history of immigration in the U.S.  But I get tired of pointing out your factual errors and flawed reasoning every single day.  You don't seem interested in dialogue or compromise.  I do believe your time will be better spent elsewhere. 

    Why do you visit this site, if I could be so bold as to ask?

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 07/30/2009 @ 08:49PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  37. Gary Stein

    "Why do you visit this site, if I could be so bold as to ask?"

    that's funny, that's what I've been wondering too (about Mr. Lindley, who i some times agree with)

     

    Here's another good question.  Mr. Lindley, does your family think you're as nuts as my family does me.  It's an obsession this blooging is; maybe I'm running for Governor as an excuse for blooging?

    Posted by Gary Stein on 07/31/2009 @ 07:04AM PT

  38. Hilary Johnson

     to be talking out of both sides of your mouth just like any other politician.  The burden is not us to please bullies and racists

     

    Bullies and racists! that had me laugh out loud. you wanna see bullies and racists, come down to my old neighborhood in LA on rampart street and look at the Mara Salvatruca gang members or the 18th street gangs. you tell me, who is the bully and racists.  the american who is frustrated that his neighborhood is turing to a thrird world country or the people who come here, sneak in, try and take everything they can from this country, send it home and laugh at the stupid gavachos.  Your assumptuntion that the american naitvists are mean because we don't want to live like people in mexico. i dont want a replica of a mexican neighborhood rebuilt next to me doesn't make me an evil person.  We have worked to hard, to give our children better, then to put up with living next to generational ignorance and poverty.  Your sence of intitlement is amusing.

    Posted by Hilary Johnson on 07/31/2009 @ 08:52AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  39. Liquids Reign

    The burden is not on us to please bullies and racists.

    Your burden, pro-advocates, is to get the laws on the books either changed or removed with a good enough reason. So until you change the minds of those who have the ability to do so, which quite honestly doesn't look to be happening, and get the Constitution re-done or an amnesty of sorts passed, it is your burden to prove why it needs to be so.

    Posted by Liquids Reign on 07/31/2009 @ 08:58AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  40. Hilary Johnson

    I will tell you why I visit this site. My parents were from the 60's. Flower children who believed that if we all just got along and brought in ever stray dog off the street we would creat a utopia society for our children. the city of seattle convinced my parents that it would be benevolent of them to send their young children from the suburbs over to the inner city urban area of seattle.(the slums) in this utopia world the suburban kids would be bussed and mix and influence the poor children and the tide would raise all the boats. Well we were bussed as children from our homes and the democrats believed by doing this we would make a nice little society. Well can you now looking back think of anything wrong with sending your children to the worst neighborhoods in your area so that the disadvantaged will rub shoulders with the advantaged. My parents though we were going to school with the cosby kids.  We were going to school with American me kids. It was rough.  but it was only 2 years and i lived and saw a different life that i would not have staying in my neighborhood. I wouldn't send my kids there, but that is water undre the bridge. So now, i'm a mom and I have my kids. Guess what I am being told now. that it is a great advantage for me to send my kids to school with the less advantage illegals kids. I've heard your songs dems and seen this dance. You could fool my parents, but you don't fool ME!

    Posted by Hilary Johnson on 07/31/2009 @ 12:06PM PT

  41. nephew bill

    this is the next governor of nj visiting his nephew bill in PA, aka as gary stein.  Hello ana lisa and mr. lindley, and welcome to the campaign hillary johnson.  not trying to be smug, just my schtick.

    i like what hilary wrote and can appreciate.  i was a full fledged dem. until i saw the same things in the 70's she was talking about, but i witnessed it on the news not first hand like her.

    must go, as if anyone cares, we're going to watch "gran torino"  Me, bill and his girlfriend

    Posted by nephew bill on 07/31/2009 @ 06:34PM PT

  42. nephew bill

    g.s. on the road at my nephews and unsure if the thread is posting.  they started the movie without me, gran torino.  liked hillary johsons comment. bye

     

    Posted by nephew bill on 07/31/2009 @ 06:39PM PT

  43. nephew bill

    what a lousy movie.  full of racist gratuity no matter if there was a message or not.  not sure if that's the right form of gratuitous?

    not in the same league as the Shootist,  if you like a good curmudgeon movie; On Golden Pond.

    Movie reviews and blogging on a Friday night hope no one minded.  i'm bold- i'm the jerk running for governor.

    Posted by nephew bill on 07/31/2009 @ 09:17PM PT

  44. nephew bill

    I did an ana lisa, got so emotional about top 2/3rds of Hillary Johnson's comment I missed the

    "I'm being told now that it is a great advantage for me to send my kids to school with the less advantage illegals kids."

    that's too complicated to say i like, but i understand where she's coming from.  and it's another sign that I'm not crazy, every one gets a half a loaf or we're never going to get any resolution on this.  only in the movies do you get that.

    Posted by nephew bill on 07/31/2009 @ 09:27PM PT

  45. Reply to thread
  46. burden is not *on us

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 03:22PM PT

  47. To get back to the topic, I thought this was a tellilng observation from the NY Times article:

    Most hospitals say that they do not conduct cross-border transfers until patients are medically stable and that they arrange to deliver them into a physician’s care in their homeland. But the hospitals are operating in a void, without governmental assistance or oversight, leaving ample room for legal and ethical transgressions on both sides of the border.

    Indeed, some advocates for immigrants see these repatriations as a kind of international patient dumping, with ambulances taking patients in the wrong direction, away from first-world hospitals to less-adequate care, if any.

    “Repatriation is pretty much a death sentence in some of these cases,” said Dr. Steven Larson, an expert on migrant health and an emergency room physician at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania. “I’ve seen patients bundled onto the plane and out of the country, and once that person is out of sight, he’s out of mind.”

    I realize that "first do no harm" is not actually in the Hippocratic Oath.  But it seems to me that it violates the spirit of the ethical practice of medicine:

    I will follow that system of regimen which, according to my ability and judgment, I consider for the benefit of my patients, and abstain from whatever is deleterious and mischievous.

     

    Posted by a d on 07/30/2009 @ 07:37PM PT

  48. Gary Stein

    too tired to tell you about my new idea, i've been busy like a fool, guess where,  since i got back from trip.  try this you-tube

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m1X6y9Gzhs

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/01/2009 @ 06:53PM PT

  49. Reply to thread
  50. Mark  Lindley

    Dave, unless our immigration policies have changed and I am not aware of it, the stats I read are that our quotas are as follows.  Asians are alotted 32% of our legal immigration quotas,   Latinos are at 28%.   All other groups are far below these percentages and whites are at the bottom of the percentage list.   So there is no discrimination really against Latinos.  If you count the number of them that are here illegally then they are making their own percentages and that just isn't fair.

    I visit this site because I am a natural debator at heart.  There are many issues facing our country today and both sides should be able to express their views on them and why they feel the way they do in order for any kind of understanding  can be reached.   Also, we all feel strongly about our opinions so it is only natural to want to enlighten those we feel are in the dark.  There is no reason to feel threatened by me or to try and silence me because we mostly disagree.   I am unafraid of hearing your opinion.    Why are you intiminated by mine?

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 07/31/2009 @ 11:21AM PT

  51. Hilary Johnson

    wow that was a good post.

    Posted by Hilary Johnson on 07/31/2009 @ 11:55AM PT

  52. Dave Bennion

    where do those numbers come from?  that's not how it works.  it's 7% per country for family-based immigrant visas, there's no formal division based on ethnicity.

    http://travel.state.gov/visa/frvi/bulletin/bulletin_4539.html

    Would your head explode if a person of Korean descent who grew up in Ecuador immigrated to the U.S.?  Or a Brazilian national of Japanese descent?  How would we classify them?

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/01/2009 @ 02:29PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  53. Reply to thread
  54. Lara Nunes

     Its sad what happened to the man, when he was forced to come to USA  and got into an car acciendent and ended up disable.

     In USA we have LAWS, which doesnt need to change.

      Those who can't understand it has nothing to do with racism, since many of us dont see it that way. We  do see how a bunch of people who thinks they are above the law and they always use the race card guilt trip on people who are law biding AMERICAN citizens.

    In Mexico it is a FELONY if a person enters their country illgeally... and their punishment is harder then ours.. but maybe we need to be like mexico have the same policies and laws..

    Under Mexican law, illegal immigration is a felony.

     Why should Obama change our laws ?  

    The General Law on Population says:

     Mexico’s main immigration law welcomes only foreigners deemed useful to Mexican society:

     _ Foreigners are admitted into Mexico “according to their possibilities of contributing to national progress.” (Article 32)

     _ Immigration officials must “ensure (that) immigrants will be useful elements for the country and that they have the necessary funds for their sustenance” and that of their dependents. (Article 34)

     _ Foreigners may be barred from the country if their presence has upset “the equilibrium of the national demographics,” if they are deemed detrimental to “economic or national interests,” if they are not good citizens in their own country, if they have broken Mexican laws, or if “they are not found to be physically or mentally healthy.” (Article 37)

     _ The secretary of governance may “suspend or prohibit the admission of foreigners when he determines it to be in the national interest.” (Article 38)

     Mexican authorities keep track of every person in the country:

    _ Federal, local and municipal police must cooperate with federal immigration authorities upon request: i.e., help in the arrest of illegal immigrants. (Article 73)

     _ A National Population Registry tracks every “individual who comprises (sic) the population of the country,” verifying each individual’s identity. (Articles 85 and 86)

     _ A national Catalogue of Foreigners tracks foreign tourists and immigrants (Article 87), assigning each a tracking number. (Article 91)

     Foreigners with fake papers or who enter the country under false pretenses may be imprisoned:

     _ Foreigners with fake immigration papers may be fined or imprisoned.

     (Article 116)

     _ Foreigners who sign government documents “with a signature that is false or different from that which he normally uses” are subject to fine and imprisonment. (Article 116)

     Foreigners who fail to obey the rules will be fined, deported, and/or imprisoned as felons:

     _ Foreigners who fail to obey a deportation order are to be punished. (Article 117)

     _ Deported foreigners who try to re-enter Mexico without authorization can be imprisoned for up to 10 years. (Article 118)

     _ Foreigners who violate terms of their visa may be sentenced for up to six years in prison. (Articles 119, 120, and 121) Foreigners who misrepresent the terms of their visa (as by working without a permit) can also be imprisoned. 

     “A penalty of up to two years in prison and a fine of 300 to 5,000 pesos will be imposed on the foreigner who enters the country illegally.” (Article 123)

     Foreigners with immigration problems may be deported, rather than imprisoned. (Article 125)

     Foreigners who “(make attempts) against national sovereignty or security” will be deported. (Article 126)

     Mexicans who help illegal aliens enter the country are considered criminals:

     A Mexican who marries a foreigner with the sole objective of helping the foreigner live in the country is subject to up to five years in prison. (Article 127)

     Shipping and airline companies that bring undocumented foreigners into Mexico will be fined. (Article 132)

    http://www.shns.com/index.php?action=detail&pk=MEXICO-04-24-06

     

     

    Posted by Lara Nunes on 07/31/2009 @ 10:47PM PT

  55. Mark  Lindley

    Those are the kinds of immigration policies that all countries should have including the U.S.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/01/2009 @ 06:44AM PT

  56. Lara Nunes

    Mark actually Alot of countries does have immigration laws which are strict, it is only certain individuals think we in USA should abolish our laws because they believe they should have FREEDOM to do as they please. Laws are place for a reason, even though our own goverment has a problem to follow it too, doesnt means all Americans citizens break laws.

    I am a law biding citizen of USA  and this is because I love my freedom .. That is what it means to have freedom.. it is when a person can follow the Laws of their country, because a Law Biding citizens has no fear living in this country.

    Posted by Lara Nunes on 08/02/2009 @ 04:02AM PT

  57. Reply to thread
  58. Hilary Johnson

    Different mentality from Mexicans and Americans. You can't shame the mexicans into forcing them to accept the illegal Salvadorians or Guatamalans into their culture. You know what they will tell you if you call them a racist because they  don't allow them into their culture, they'll tell you go to hell. This is where the grassroots efforts should be based. If someone has as strong indignaiton for unjustice as they want us to believe why wouldn't they be demonstrating here.  It would seem they an agenda   rather then fighting for the downtroden. Lots of down troden in Mexico that need a loud voice.  This article is kinda old, but i doubt much has changed. Apparently kids can't go to school in mexico if they don't have a passport and illegals are rounded up in hospitals. where is the outcry?

    http://migration.ucdavis.edu/mn/comments.php?id=515_0_2_0_C

    Posted by Hilary Johnson on 08/01/2009 @ 12:09PM PT

  59. Dave Bennion

    The outcry i'm sure is from immigrant rights activists in Mexico, who I would happily host on this blog in solidarity.  it's not an either/or situation ... i'm not happy with the Mexican government's response to migration, the UK's government, Italy's, China's, etc. ... but i live in the u.s. and so that is where i focus my efforts at present.

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/01/2009 @ 02:22PM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 1 person likes this comment.   Like
  60. Gary Stein

    "i'm not happy with the Mexican government's response to migration,"

    I'm back, I was daydreaming,  looking up and watching you tubes.  They pulled a 1965 version of just Neil Young singing his song "Nowadays Clancy Can't Even Sing"  From before he was famous and his talent was so obvious, it's a shame it was pulled.  The money grubbing s.o.b was probably responsible for having it banned, he just released some ridiculously expensive compilation of his career.  I'm not going to get in trouble am I for posting you tubes here?  I have exquisite taste in music and I know the immigration situation (upside down and right side up) and that we have to get together as a group.  A boycott by the way is the only new idea in this old, old mix.

    daydreaming, watching the clock turn

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbZq4RQ2PDc

     

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/01/2009 @ 05:49PM PT

  61. Ah yes, I can see it now.  You, Dave and some fifth-string reporter will sail into Mexico on a mission -- nothing less than to exhort the Mexican people to boycott their own government!  And you will accomplish this while swimming in Beto's pool and scarfing down his mother's world-famous chile rellenos (Mmm...muy saboroso!), while your Mexican neighbors are worrying about the price of tortillas and where their next meal is coming from.  Ah, but they be stirred by your rallying grito: "Stein para los Pueblos!"  Gringos in bathing suits always did look cute(especially on spring break! ;-)  Ah, but you will be the spark that ignites the coming revolution so that the people can finally free themselves from the oppressive yoke of corruption and elitism  (que deja vu!...ever read Orwell's Animal Farm?). Yes, it would make a great script and you have a fantasic imagination, Gary.  I really think you should write it because that's the only way it's going to happen. It would make it a great comedy (with Astrud Gilberto crooning in the background ;-)

    Posted by a d on 08/01/2009 @ 07:16PM PT

  62. *sabroso (typo)

    Posted by a d on 08/01/2009 @ 07:19PM PT

  63. Gary Stein

    i laugh at all of you.  that's not exactly how i envision the trip.......it would be hush, hush when we got there.  have you read any of my "diaries" have you seen my web site (any of them) 

    It’s dangerous down there!  mucho peligroasa

    can’t sit and stay very long in headquarters- the computer laundry room, have to go play softball shortly and then work.  So let’s cut through all the bull shit, why don't we…………hears my favorite you tube, she’s dynamite isn’t she?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_vAwKnFlQk

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 03:43AM PT

  64. Gary Stein

    scroll down, read my you tube comment, register if you have to and recommend, it's embarrassing i have no recommends.  i don't just go off the cuff when i say things, i said "no charisma" i meant it.  the no recommends is proof.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 03:48AM PT

  65. Gary Stein

    so sorry, and this...i'm not surprised mr. "have gone will travel", wire paladin is gone, but where is liquid, did he get banned?  does anyone else worry about him (Mr. Lindley, Hillary?)

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 03:51AM PT

  66. Lara Nunes

    Hilary

    I agree  I get tired by some of the people who calls some americans racists, when many  of that is untrue.. Not all of us Americans are racists, it just we dont think they should be above the laws of our country and if they want to be here, then follow the laws and come here LEGALLY...

    There has been many people who is still on the waiting list who applied for a green card  and came here with a visa .These other people who comes here illegally those who jumped the borders.. shouldnt have the right to get anything.. since like mexico its a felony to be illegal... and it should be that way here tooo.

    Now the people who were transported here by coyotes... they should be freed from their new found slave masters and if they have the money be able to get a work visa...

     and if they are living here after they got their work visa I believe its 2 years being a law biding citizen they can apply for a green card. Because those people were forced to be here, no different then any other slaves who were forced to be here...

    I have no issues with people coming to USA, just follow the bloody laws and everything will be ok.

    Posted by Lara Nunes on 08/02/2009 @ 04:17AM PT

  67. Gary Stein

    i'm making a mess of every body's in-box, this is definitely last one for now must get going.

    ana lisa, as far as that idea of yours for me to write about my experiences, you’ll appreciate the next you tube, my nephew showed me this Friday night, but putting it in this context is all me. 

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqrfYNCvHSE&feature=channel_page

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 04:18AM PT

  68. Dave Bennion

    the people who were transported here by coyotes... they should be freed from their new found slave masters and if they have the money be able to get a work visa...

    I assume you are talking about some new reform, because under the laws of our country that now exist what you propose is almost always impossible, especially if the person leaves the U.S. and tries to reenter lawfully.

    Most who cross the border come with coyotes, so I'm not sure who it is exactly that you're so upset about for not following our laws.

    and if they are living here after they got their work visa I believe its 2 years being a law biding citizen they can apply for a green card.

    Do you mean work visa or work permit?  There's a big difference.  How would someone become a law abiding citizen before they get their green card?  And it's normally 5 years as a green card holder before a person can apply for citizenship.  I think you are very confused about how the laws work.

    Because those people were forced to be here, no different then any other slaves who were forced to be here...

    That is not true in most cases either.  Most people who pay smugglers come here of their own accord to try to find a better life for themselves and their families.  This is not true of trafficking victims, of course.  Some who come here willingly later fall into trafficking, male and female.

    Posted by Dave Bennion on 08/02/2009 @ 06:55AM PT

  69. Gary Stein

    "fifth string reporter" I was specifically looking for a New York Times reporter, but I'll settle for a Philadelphia Inquirer since that's where Dave lives and works and I'm close by.

    "exhort the Mexican people to boycott their own government"  you don't mean Mexicans in Mexico, that country is in the hopper- nothing worth boycotting

    "While swimming in Beto's pool."  Beto doesn't have a pool, unless you mean the sickening, disgusting smelly stream that runs next to the house his brothers still live in.  I know every detail of the history of that stream, the one he was able to swim in as a child, which wasn't that long ago.  I think Al Gore was already in the Senate and a Pres. candidate one time already.

    you got the part about Chile Renos correct.  And all of it taken together would make a great comedy, I've said it many times myself.  Ben Stiller with Astrud Gilberto playing in the background.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kqsda-1h_y8&feature=related

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 05:21PM PT

  70. Reply to thread
  71. Mark  Lindley

    Gary, think about this then.   What would happen if we took in all the world's poor and needy here?   You don't think that would overpopulate our country?   Do you realize across the globe how many there are?   Do you think we could provide them all with jobs, housing, natural resurces, medical, education?    How many more roads, houses, schools, hospitals would we have to build?  Would there be any more undeveloped land left for wildlife and just for humans to enjoy?   How about culture clash since so many would be from so many different ethnic groups with cultural practices that don't fit with ours?   You don't think we wouldn't be a nation of non-communication with so many different languages being spoken and many not desiring to learn our language?   It doesn't make sense and it isn't fair to us to empty out dozens of countries of their poor citizens and bring them here while the rest of their rich citizenry enjoy sparsely populated countries with an abundance of land and resources.   Think, Gary!

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/02/2009 @ 08:51AM PT

  72. Gary Stein

    Mark, Dave asked me how Beto would feel if he knew I threw around the word "illegals"  Would you like to know how Beto feels about the border fence and stepped up security which did in fact prevent him from coming back to the US last year (7 times)?  I'm sure he wishes it was the way it used to be, but he and I have discussed attitudes like yours, Mr. Lunes, Liquid, etc. (throw in me)  He understands and quite agrees with the necessity for the fence...and don't anyone say it's because he's repeating what I want to hear!!  So does that partly answers Daves query about the word "illegals"?  if not lst me finish it off, Beto could give two flying f's about words.  What he's interested in is making money.

    Mark I'm talking about a one more-one time- last time amnesty, wouldn't you dig it if the Mexicans here illegally en Mass didn't send back remittances in gratitude to our largess (amnesty) with the goal of shaming Mexico's politicians and law makers.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 05:38PM PT

  73. Gary Stein

    Mark Hugell is back, na,na,na,na,na

    "where have you been? i know, i know comcast!  all the action is over at

    http://immigration.change.org/blog/view/all-white_florida_jury_sanctions_private_deportations_by_hospital

    maybe you didn't know,you wouldn't have gotten the e-mails.

    Here's a big problem, are you listening ana lisa, every one skims the threads, including ana lisa, either when they jump into the debate late, or there's 10 e-mail's in the in box.  I'll answer your last question if you first go to my web site

    http://steinforgovernor.com

    and then still not sure, I will answer why governor.   You sound like the only middle of the roader besides me commenting, but I admit I skimmed some of your responses.  But did you see where i praised your one comment and that was when I just got into discussing immigration on this site.  I picked up on you right away.  Dave, and all the others don't realize people like you and me are in the majority."

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 05:57PM PT

    .......................................................................

    Mr. Stein,

    I was offline for nine days due to a COMCAST technician accidentally disconnecting me. Dealing with that company was Kafkaesque. This blog appears to have run its course, thus I don't plan on commenting more.

    I would probably be described as a liberal or even left of that, but I welcome all viewpoints. But, the Hitler stuff was a bit much. I brought that as an example of how following the Bible or law blindly could lead one into such moral travesties. I believe another reason why some, such as Liquid Reigns, were banned was because they weren't using their real names and some of the commentary was getting sharp and was straying way off topic.

    I don't believe that Mr. Lindley was banned. I may not agree with him, but he was a gentleman as far as how he expressed his opinions.

    Why are you running for governor? Don't you think that you should try to get elected to some lower office first to get some experience regarding how government works?

    ....................................................................

    if you're left or left of center then i must be a liberal too.

     

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/02/2009 @ 06:02PM PT

  74. Lara Nunes

    DAVE said : I assume you are talking about some new reform, because under the laws of our country that now exist what you propose is almost always impossible, especially if the person leaves the U.S. and tries to reenter lawfully.

    No I am talking about people who are sex slaves and the ones who were kidnapped, should be freed and their slave mastered excuted.

    The coyotes and the american corporation who funded and advertised there were jobs here,should be abolished and sent to gitmo.

    I have ever reason to be upset, since many of these people are crossing over here on lies based on some people who claims there is work .There is no work here only free welfare.

    Dave said:

    Do you mean work visa or work permit?  There's a big difference.  How would someone become a law abiding citizen before they get their green card? 

    Normally when a person comes over here legally with a visa like my parents did in 1968, they applied for a green card.Because they didnt break any laws and we came here by plane... so of coarse it was legal we had passports.

    I am not confused by the LAWs in USA, since I follow it more then some laywers and judges and presidents and the govt.Well if you remember I said I THINK it is 2 years,that a green card holder can become americans citizens.. so therefore it means you cant read very well can you... ?

    And sex slaves are not just mexicans theere are american children who are kidnapped from USA and smuggled to be sold in Mexico and all over the place in the world, are you saying forget the children ?

    Most people who came here was because they were lied there were jobs here and the sad part about it the innocent women and children did not asked to become sex slaves.. I support the sex slaves to be freed, since these people are FORCED to do something they didnt want to do. The illegals who jumped the border .. go home

     

     

    Posted by Lara Nunes on 08/02/2009 @ 08:40PM PT

  75. Gary Stein

    Ana lisa, you think i want to go to Mexico and be hooping and hollering?  Ms. Nunes comment had me scrambling back to look up this information.  And you say I don't read enough?

    read this!  just the type of country we want on our southern border.....but i at least have a way to try and begin fixing-  boycott.

    Dave's not interested!  read this

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/31/AR2007033101359.html

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/03/2009 @ 05:14AM PT

  76. Gary Stein

    I hope everyone reads, I just either read or re-read.  No, I don't think I read the entire article before, I know I heard the last 5 minutes of Cacho being interviewed on NPR late one spring night and I then looked her up on internet and found that article.

    Had I read the entire article I would have gone crazy because Puebla is the same police department Beto and  I turned over an $800 bribe- shakedown, and threat! All we could do was negotiate it down from $2000.  They where going to put him in jail if we didn't pay- and they where going to physically beat me where it wouldn't show, if I didn't either leave without him or get out of my truck.  This was right in front of the Puebla police station after being led there by one cop and his backup from where the original "traffic violation" occured ( the Chief was standing right there during all this at the station!!!)  And i never did get out of the car but the bastards did get the $800.  For that $800 and 4 wasted hours the chief kindly had one "officer" show us the way back to the highway towards Mexico City.  The officer was on another Harley Davidson, they all had , the only town that did.  No need to get silly and put a you-tube of Brando and Lee Marvin, in was it the Wild One or Wild Bunch.

    After that nothing went right that night driving my Suburban, the one I was giving him.  Traffic jams, road construction, speed bumps (rushing to make up for lost time and speed bumps and no street lights) missing street signs etc.  It was about 3pm and 80 degrees when it all started in Puebla; by the time we finished negotiating it was freezing.  (He was in and out of the police headquarters, with an escort of course, and he had on shorts and a nothing t-shirt (guinee tee, can I say that).  All that time I was sitting in the drivers seat with an idiot cop leaning in passenger window trying in pathetic English to "dope" out how much money we where probably carrying.)

    After the police escort waved bye, bye you should have seen the road construction and delays on the main highway out of town.  They had miles and miles of the right most lane cordoned off but you only saw a few construction vehicles.  Nothing but nothing makes sense down there. 

    I forgot to mention that they tried to be real cute at the end, after we paid, and said they where impounding the car overnight. I'm sure the truck would have been 100% the next day.  Also I snuck a cell phone call out to my friend back in jersey and told him we might be in deep doo doo but the battery died after about a minute.  Stein for Governor, right.

    Mr. Lindley, Dave and ana lisa never follow up when I mischievously ask them to ask me a question.  You don't like Mexico and I have very mixed feelings about it myself.  Ask me how the trouble started in Puebla?  Ask me what we witnessed the very next day in another police station the next town over from Beto.  We where just bystanders, but it was actually more cynical than what we dealt with the night before.  Ask me why Beto deserved that truck in the first place, better have a hanky ready

    Even though the fence will slow the migration to a virtual halt, the disease will still be down there.  And sorry Mr. Lindley, I have to laugh yet again, you think the 10 to 12 million here are going to wander back there if we sanction employers?

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/03/2009 @ 06:25AM PT

  77. Gary Stein

    sorry, I meant to say, now I have to laugh at Mr. Lindley having said the same about Dave and ana lisa.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/03/2009 @ 06:28AM PT

  78. Reply to thread
  79. Lara Nunes

    Gary,

    There is a place you can check to see how many children are kidnapped and sold into sex slavery. The media will not broadcast these issues because to them it isnt important.

    In my heart and soul these children, no matter what race they are shouldnt be subjected to this kind of things. Think of it this way, notice how many american children are coming up missing? think about where they went to and why and the sad part about it many of the children are found dead because the law inforcers or the govt are not looking at the right direction.

    The way I see it, maybe we need to invade mexico and find these children who are americans and then arrest the mexico police people for supporting this crime...

    We as Americans have to protect our own, because no one else is doing it and the sex slave masters are getting away with this crime with a slap on the wrist.

    When certain things are cover up, it is because there is a crime that been committed.

    here is the website about the many children and women and even little boys who are subjected to human trafficking.

     If people really cares this is the issues which is really important.

    http://www.polarisproject.org/

    http://www.humantrafficking.org/

     

    Posted by Lara Nunes on 08/03/2009 @ 12:06PM PT

  80. Gary Stein

    Lara, I'm so tired and I'm going to make a point of not going to links because it's my way of showing Mr. Benion I comprehend why nobody goes to my links either, we're all run ragged, there's too much stuff to read.

    I'm sorry and maybe just to be contrary I will go to them later.  Either way my heart is with you 100%.  You're on the right side of an important issue and nobody gives a hoot. I know the feeling.

    There's a lot of nasty stuff going on in Mexico and for the life of me I wish Dave and Company would explain how outside of a boycott we could change anything.   Oh, I know, by blogging! That will change the other 299,999,994 Americans minds. Tomorrow they'll wake up and read this blog.

     

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/03/2009 @ 05:31PM PT

  81. Reply to thread
  82. Gary,

    You appear to be so full of helium, that I'm tempted to tie weights to your ankles to keep you here on terra firma...grounded to reality.  Listen, the only ones who might  buy your boycott idea are the most rabid of the restrictionists.  But the moment you say the word "amnesty" you lose them, no?  (try to focus on how people are responding to you.)  The Democrats and Republicans are all gung ho for these free trade bills because they sing to the tune of the corporate piper who lines their pockets.  So, you're not going to convince them of a boycott. Nor are you going to persuade the Mexican people to stop sending remittances to family members who depend on them.

    To answer your question, I am a voracious reader when I am interested in a subject.  However, I do tend skim or ignore the comments of the restrictionists.  I've heard their arguments so many times, I could recite them in my sleep. And as you've noticed, they sound like automatons half the time.  And sincce you did not take the time to answer any of my questions or respond to the articles I linked to, I'm wondering why I should respond to you.  Gary, I rather like you...you appear to have a heart and some measure of compassion unlike most nativists.  But I am not here to flirt with you.  I'm a reasonably intelligent person, so if you don't take me seriously, why should I waste my time? 

    But you are right about one thing: you won't make money writing a script, but it would be a better use of your time than running for Governor.  It doesn't appear to me that you are having much success convincing either side.  Has that dawned on you yet? 

    Posted by a d on 08/03/2009 @ 04:14PM PT

  83. Gary Stein

    hello my friend (and critic), obviously I responded to you over at

     http://immigration.change.org/blog/view/bill_moyers_interviews_former_health_insurance_

    insider_wendell_potter

    I'm so tired and the night is still young

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAmfx0ZIZlA

     

     

     

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/03/2009 @ 05:39PM PT

  84. Here's a video for you Gary...that is, if you care to get serious by actually addressing the topic at hand:

    http://video.nytimes.com/video/2008/08/03/us/1194817111333/the-deportation-of-luis-jimenez.html

    Posted by a d on 08/04/2009 @ 11:30AM PT

  85. Gary Stein

    I meant to  bring a headset with me to Fort Lauderdale to use in the library.  sorry my dear.  i'd never talk that way in person.

    i'll try and borrow a set.  i see something about the deportation of luis jimenez, i'll google his name.  i'm not for deporting my friends from Mexico if there here minding their own business.  anyway thanks for keeping up the dialogue even if we sometimes skim.  Dave is a busy guy posting one story per day it seems.  what better place to gather original, original material than Mexico.  hasn't anyone noticed all the original stories i have to tell?  and am i obnoxious?  you seem to be my only regular pen pal.  or is my middle ground position to unsettling for the others?  library closing will google his name real quick.  good night

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/04/2009 @ 04:47PM PT

  86. Gary Stein

    Ana lisa, as I said yesterday I’m at the library with no head set and I’ve extended my session a few times already,  but I did a google and re-read the same information on Louis Jimenez that’s above?  So what’s up?  I’m 100% on your side on this issue.  If you’re focusing on this incident, is it because you read my account of Maria and Pallone in another thread.  Pallone the guy I knew who was minding his own business working on the back of a sanitation truck (on the books Mr. Lindley) when a maniac white kid side swiped with his uninsured car and threw Pallone into the next county and paralyzed him for life?   You did read?

     p.s. I’m at library working on my 500 word essay that every candidate has an opportunity to have sent to every registered voter in the state of New Jersey.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/05/2009 @ 02:16PM PT

  87. Good luck, Gary.  Listen, I think you need to make up your mind who you support: people like your friend Beto and Pallone, or the restrictionists who would sell them down the river, because frankly they don't care about undocumented peoples.  I suggest you take at least a month and interview Latinos --both citizens and undocumented workers -- and their allies.  Go door to door and find out what's going on in the communities (don't just ask Beto).  Talk to churches and organizations who work with migrants.  Even if your footwork doesn't pay off in this election, it will later. Latinos are the growing in numbers and influence, and will likely influence future elections.  So, it would be a smart move for any politician to get to know this community and find out what their issues are.  Find out about 287(g)...in fact, I handed you this issue as a gift, but you didn't recognize it.  Obama is talking about racial profiling now.  I predict that this is going to become a very issue in the near future, because we are not going to let him get away with hypocrisy on an issue that's so important to the Latino community.  This is a civil rights and human rights issue...so it is an issue that resonates with Latinos.  Imagine if you were the one politician with enough courage to address when no one else was.  This would put you in a very good position for future campaigns.  But you must learn how to listen, focus in on what's important to people and become more serious about what you believe.  People pick up on the fact that you're giving them a song and dance right now.  That's probably why they don't take you too seriously. 

    As I said, I rather like you, Gary because you seem to have some compassion for undocumented people, like your friend Beto. But you're going to have to ask yourself what and who you're willing to fight for.  Then show the courage of your convictions and moral beliefs.  If you're just trying to get everyone on your side by proposing some "pie in the sky" compromise, you won't convince anyone.  In order to know what you're talking about, you need to start listening to the folks you're interested in helping. Then maybe your campaign will be meaningful...it will be based on more than just a desire for money or recognition.  In order for us to believe in you, you have to believe in something besides yourself and your campaign.  Why are you running Gary?  I still don't have a clear idea about this.  Why is it important to you?  If you can't articulate this clearly, no one is going to be swayed by your ideas, no matter how wonderful you think they are.  Listen, I know I'm giving you a hard time, but the voters are going to ask you even tougher questions....and they deserve serious answers from would-be candidates. If you're running out the door every time someone poses a tough question you can't answer, what are you going to do if you do find that elusive reporter?  Do you think the pundits are going to wait for you while you google 287(g) to find out what it's about or why it matters to the Latino community? So, take some time, do some research...then come back and talk to us about the Stein for Governor campaign, k?  All the best.

    Posted by a d on 08/05/2009 @ 03:07PM PT

  88. Gary Stein

    Ana lisa, I’m thrilled again you’d take the time to respond with such a detailed, personal response but please, just as you’re so sure I’m not listening and evaluating, look at yourself, your allies and also the “restictionists” as you call them.  Neither side has made on iota’s difference in the other sides view of things on this blog as far as I can tell; I’m at least suggesting a compromise. 

    Now you say a cautious Obama is hedging his bets on the 287g statute, and then look at what’s getting thrown in his face with the health care reform.  Do you think if he was even inclined to use any more precious political capital on amnesty, some of the idiots from my party wouldn’t have a field day?  And don’t think there’s going to be town hall meetings on this issue, it’s a non-starter.   In other words he’s going to propose reform and then run like hell hoping Hispanics will remember how he tried.  These (politicians) are the most cynical bastards in the world for good reason.  You might not have to live with the “restictionists” but the politicians have to consider them and with good reason.  That’s where your naiveté is showing.  Who’s tested their theories out on the middle group of Americans like me?  Nobody. Who’s been where I’ve been that’s running for political office? Nobody.  Since I don’t have the sheckles to hire my own polling company I’ll go with my own gut feeling about the whole issue i.e., boycott.  Boycott- you make it sound like I invented the word.

    You want to know why I’m running or you’re not sure; do I have to say again.  It’s a stunt pure and simple to get one reporter, or a group to go down to Mexico with me with two purposes in mind.  One to help promote my agenda thereby helping Beto…but that has taken a backseat since I discovered how hard headed people are, to now hoping there’s one chance in a thousand that someone eventually will do a documentary on the guinness world record holder, me, for being  the biggest pain in the ass- plain and simple.  Maybe there will be some financial gain come out of it for me and mine and Beto and his.  It’s the Republican way and that’s a good thing and nothing to apologize for.

    And as far as speaking to undocumented workers, depending on how the question is asked, you could elicit any response you’d like.  I’ll spell this out, not for the last time,  …..Mr. and Mrs. Undocumented, if there was no other pathway to amnesty but  some fool’s idea who’s running for Governor-  and that idea could magically put an amnesty proposal on the table so that maybe the Mr. Lindley’s and ana lisa’s of the world can’t block it, because the enormous middle ground of moderates like me see the potential to resolve once and for all- would you not send remittances back to your family for 3 or 4 months in order to capture the attention of the despicable corrupt government of Mexico (current President excluded).

    Ana lisa I don’t have to decide which side to support because there’s a third side, mine.  When I say I’m for closing the border I mean it.  Any one who’s honest about it, including “undocumented” persons knows the reason.  The status quo is like some one being half pregnant.  They’ll keep coming and coming and coming across- and getting people not as gentlemanly as Mr. Lindley even angrier, and angrier, and then what happens eventually?  Starts with the letter…..V…….  I get it; maybe that’s what both sides want- a vigilante war.

    Posted by Gary Stein on 08/06/2009 @ 01:54PM PT

  89. Reply to thread
  90. Mark  Lindley

    I am still waiting to hear what the heck and who the heck is a restrictionist.   Laws are restrictrive by nature but people?   WTH does that mean?   Who coined such an idiotic word for people anyway?   Not anyone who makes any sense that's for sure.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/03/2009 @ 07:32PM PT

  91. Hilary Johnson

    Mark, have you ever heard of a country that didn't restrict how many foreigners come into their land. I mean if there aren't any restrictions that have to prevent a takeover. That was where we were heading pre 911.  I still haven't heard any of the anti Americans come up with a finite number on how many is enough so that we are seen as a compassionate society. If we take in 20 million would that be enough? If we take in 20 million they by law could bring in 40 million. If we let mothers and fathers come in, they have to bring in all of their family or else we are still mean, nativists. America needs to stay the course.

    Posted by Hilary Johnson on 08/03/2009 @ 11:58PM PT

  92. Reply to thread
  93. Lara Nunes

    Mark the people who made of those words are people who wants illegals to have a free pass to USA,, they want to by pass the laws of USA... If  they want to call names the right names for them  is Anti American, since they want to break laws andthey support breaking laws...

    Here is someing I am sure analisa doesnt understand.. more likely she doesnt care, but some americans who are LAW BIDING CITIZENS because we FOLLOW THE LAWS ... care about people who would follow them too. The way I see it, if they can break the LAWS of Immigration.. what other laws will they break ?

    CHAPTER 2 -- QUALIFICATIONS FOR ADMISSION OF ALIENS; TRAVEL CONTROL OF CITIZENS AND ALIENS

    INA: ACT 211- DOCUMENTARY REQUIREMENTS

    http://www.uscis.gov/propub/ProPubVAP.jsp?dockey=c9fef57852dc066cfe16a4cb816838a4

    Anyone with a brain to think knows,  people who has no papers or visa or passport is allowed into the USA or any country which has immigration laws.

     INA: TITLE III

     CHAPTER 2 -- NATIONALITY THROUGH NATURALIZATION

    INA: ACT 311 - ELIGIBILITY FOR NATURALIZATION

    http://www.uscis.gov/propub/ProPubVAP.jsp?dockey=c9fef57852dc066cfe16a4cb816838a4

    INA: ACT 312 - REQUIREMENTS AS TO UNDERSTANDING THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE, HISTORY, PRINCIPLES, AND FORM OF GOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES

    http://www.uscis.gov/propub/ProPubVAP.jsp?dockey=c9fef57852dc066cfe16a4cb816838a4

    How many illegals in USA can READ,WRITE,SPEAK  English really knows the HISTORY of USA? ummmm not many .

    I have ridden the train of Immigration, but I and my parents entered Legally into this country, something we cant say for the illegals can we.

     

     

     

    Posted by Lara Nunes on 08/03/2009 @ 08:02PM PT

  94. Mark  Lindley

    I know what you are mean, Lara.   The anti-laws people use name calling on pro-laws people to shed a bad and false light on them.   The light should in fact be shed on themselves instead.

    Posted by Mark Lindley on 08/04/2009 @ 05:21PM PT

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

Author
Dave Bennion

David is an attorney in Philadelphia, PA, where he helps immigrants to the U.S. navigate the complex immigration legal system. Views he expresses at change.org are his alone and don't represent the views or opinions of his employer, Nationalities Service Center. The information contained on this site is intended for educational and advocacy purposes only.

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.