ALIPAC Feeling Challenged by Volunteer-Run Network
Published October 12, 2009 @ 01:19PM PT
In order to combat the upcoming introduction of an immigration bill, a hilarious message came from nativist William Gheen over the weekend about his efforts to increase ALIPAC's social media presence:
Currently we have 1,012 supporters on Myspace, 2,624 supporters on Facebook, and 8,067 supporters on Twitter!
As usual, William Gheen is exaggerating. His numbers on Myspace and Facebook are not even close to impressive and he has 6900 followers on Twitter, courtesy the fact that he follows more than 7500 people. Obviously, people usually reciprocate and follow back. ALIPAC has been on the web since September 2004 and yet, there is nothing impressive about the pageviews it gets when compared to recently established promigrant spaces:

Nonetheless, his exaggerations turn into outright lies a little later:
Our biggest competitor and the current leader out of all of the pro/con groups are the Dream Act Amnesty activists with their large financial budget. While ALIPAC is kicking their tails on Twitter, they are ahead of us on Myspace with 5,569 supporters and 43,070 people in support of their cause on Facebook!
It is a huge compliment that William Gheen considers a handful of undocumented youth to be his main competitors rather than the multi-million Reform Immigration for America. But he is certainly wrong about any 'large financial budget.' The DREAM Act network is volunteer run and funded by undocumented youth who are working 2-3 jobs at a time, struggling to afford college, bearing the brunt of deportation proceedings while living in poor social conditions.
But this is also the same volunteer-run network that put on 108 actions in 26 states last month and 'mock graduation' events in 16 states this past June, drawing thousands of participants for these grassroots actions. By comparison, William Gheen has only 24 people signed up for his astro-turf 'tea parties against amnesty' in over 3 states on November 14! The fact that nativists can only draw about two dozen protestors is not news to anyone. But William Gheen, just be honest about who you are competing against: less than a dozen unfunded, undocumented youth who simply want to stay and contribute to this country, through passage of a legislation that will benefit only about 300,000 educated young people.
If that is your biggest competition in your battle against what you label as amnesty, good luck winning the war.
Share this Post
Related Posts
-
Anti-Immigration Forces Dwindling
-
Napolitano Speaks: The Price for Immigration Reform
-
Victory: Lou Dobbs Takes Voluntary Departure from CNN
Comments (8)
Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.
Author
-
Prerna obtained her Masters degree in International Relations in 2007 and took a hiatus from academia. During this break, she co-founded DreamActivist.org and helped launch a program for immigrant youth in the Bay Area (S4FC). Currently, she is also a Managing Editor at The Sanctuary. Views expressed on this blog are her own and not that of any organization currently affiliated with her. Contact email - prerna@change.org
Facebook
Twitter
Digg
StumbleUpon
Delicious
Email


















Prerna, I'm glad to see this cause is up and running again. You are brave.
America's unemployment rate is estimated to be around 17%, right now. And we all know, when people are poor, they need someone to blame. Immigrants do make for an easy target; not that I see thousands of Americans lining up for minimum wage jobs. My point: we're all going about this the wrong way.
We,(at this point,) don't need anymore legislation. What we need is employment. Real employment that people can support their families on. Instead of appealing to the American peoples empathy, and generosity,(which there is little left;) I suggest appealing to their greed.
We've all seen Obama's version of rearranging the wealth. The stock market is up, and so is the poverty level. Which only goes to prove; he made the rich, richer. Or you could sum it up as, "free trade, in NO way, is fair trade." I know the tea-parties, are also against free-trade. So, if you could appeal to the greed of the U.S. citizens, have them drop the amnesty issue; in trade, your side supports the "free-trade issue," the possibility for both sides getting what they want, would be more likely.
Posted by L.S. hope on 10/12/2009 @ 09:08PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
I just honestly think the Anti-Amnesty ALIPACKERS are running their parade mightly thin these days. It looks like healthcare reform is going to pass and quite frankly if our president can move that bill we have made it through the storm.
Immigration Reform just might be the breath of fresh air to this Administration when it becomes totally on the plate. With only 15% of our US Citizens on the opposition and 64% wanting the bill to pass "including a path to citizenship" pressure is going to be on our congress and the opposition is going to look more than silly. Plus Americans are going to be a fan of our President knowing they have healthcare reform so they will want him to continue his work.
I am having visions of the "ALIPACKERS" they are going to have a typical parade of stamping their feet and beating their chests with their usual rhetoric and I am surely going to want front row seats. This is going to be quite a circus show of freaks this time around.
Posted by Mary Pranzatelli on 10/13/2009 @ 07:46PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
I agree we need employment--creation of more jobs, more services as well as fair labor practices. If we don't have fair labor practices in all countries, people will continue to migrate AND get exploited when they arrive here by scrupulous employers. But I also don't doubt that we have a broken immigration system with 11.8 million people in the shadows who also need to be integrated into society.
Posted by Prerna Lal on 10/13/2009 @ 08:13PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
The 11.8 million are amongst us everyday. They are our family, friends....and they are a part of many of us who are citizens of this country. They are our life. The lack of integration can be extremely hurtful to the people who care about them because of the segregation within peers/friends that are legal and the ones that are not. Than you reach out and help then and bitterness forms because of that feeling of neediness between you and them which is unfair to both. They want the freedom to have the opportunitys that you have and you want them to have them so you can simply feel equal. You know that you are equal as humans but you still have a barrier and that is broken laws that cripple you both. The sooner reform comes the faster the healing process takes place nationwide.
Segregation cause nothing more than dysfunction in society. It makes dysfuncional familys and angry bitter people. I know kids that have parents that lack status. It must be difficult to go to school facing other children from drastically different background. Its hard enough being a kid and going through growing pains. We need to change the system but I am afraid the healing process will takes years. Sometimes growing up we lack opportunity's and guidence that other kids had but then we also blossom at an amazing rate that the others haven't simple because we have such a strong desire to overcome the obsticle's and fears. Many times those hardships turn out to be benefits later on in life.
Posted by Mary Pranzatelli on 10/13/2009 @ 09:40PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Hi Mary,
The good thing about the immigration reform debate would be that ALIPACers and their allies don't have crazy money like big pharma. They just make a bunch of angry phone calls and block fax lines. That's what the 'Left' (if there is such a thing as a monolithic left) needs to get better at doing.
Posted by Prerna Lal on 10/13/2009 @ 08:15PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Yes Prerna...Great point! the pharma's have big crazy amounts of money. It's hard to fight them but it looks like we might beat them???
The ALIPACers know how to make themselves look bigger than they are. The left needs to get louder but I think we are getting there. If there is a monolithic left I think I might be a part of it??? hehe
Posted by Mary Pranzatelli on 10/13/2009 @ 08:37PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Haha, we are too busy fighting each other over strategies. At least the 'Right' seems united in the hatred at times. But on immigration reform, it is a small group of extremists that make the most noise. Business, libertarians and Evangelicals are on our side so that is a good thing.
Posted by Prerna Lal on 10/14/2009 @ 07:06PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
That reminds me of that episode of South Park I saw. I am sure you have seen it. Its the left...and the right and many of the talking points on Immigration. My niece showed this episod one day but I can't remember the name of it. I will have to ask her. I almost died laughing. It was a great comic approach example of all the extremists. The character that represented the "left" was so funny and reminded me of my own talking points.
Posted by Mary Pranzatelli on 10/14/2009 @ 08:09PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.